Sun, shade and wind: how much light each part of the yard really gets
Four readings through one clear day at each spot that will hold plants, a band on one stated scale, a dated winter re-check, and the wind and the hot walls marked.
- Start here: the essentials
- 1. Why light is measured and not described
- 2. The bands, on one stated scale
- 3. The method: four readings and a total
- 4. Summer sun, winter sun, and the re-check
- 5. Wind, and the breeze you do not want blocked
- 6. Microclimates: hot walls, cold hollows
- 7. What planting does to the house
- 8. See it: three readings
- 9. Practice: read the light
- 10. Your garden
- 11. Check your work
- 12. Knowledge check and scenario
Start here Essentials
Light is the first thing a plant tag asks about and the thing gardeners most often guess. One clear day and five short looks settle it for a bed. Everything marked Go deeper is optional on a first pass.
- Pick the spots that will hold plants. Three is plenty for one bed; a whole yard needs one per part that behaves differently (section 3).
- Look at each spot five times tomorrow, around 8, 10, 12, 2 and 4, and write down direct sun or not (section 3).
- Total the hours and write the band, on the one scale this manual uses (section 2).
- Date the winter re-check on the sun sheet, for before the leaves come out (section 4).
Minimum time: five looks of two minutes each, across one day. Done when: every spot on the survey's sun sheet has a number of hours and a band beside it, and one dated re-check is written down.
1. Why light is measured and not described Understand
Ask anyone about their yard and you will get an adjective: sunny, shady, bright, dark. Ask them how many hours of direct sun the bed by the fence gets and most people have no idea, because nobody has ever stood there five times in a day. That gap is where most plant failures come from, and it is the cheapest gap in the whole manual to close.
Two things make description unreliable. The first is that human beings are poor at judging light levels, because the eye adapts: a shaded corner at midday looks bright because your pupils have opened, and the same corner photographed looks as dark as it is. The second is that "sunny" describes an impression of the whole yard at the one hour you happen to be in it, and a yard is not uniform. The bed against the house and the bed against the back fence can be two bands apart.
What matters to a plant is not brightness but hours of direct sun: hours when the sun itself is on the spot, unobstructed. Physical principle Bright shade and direct sun differ by roughly an order of magnitude in the energy arriving, which is why a plant tagged for full sun flowers poorly in a place that feels perfectly bright. "Direct sun" has a test that needs no equipment: stand at the spot and see whether you are standing in sunlight or in shadow.
Both Oklahoma State Extension and NC State Extension treat this as a survey item to be recorded on the drawing rather than remembered. Oklahoma State's instruction is to indicate on your map which areas receive full sun, part sun or shade. NC State's plant-selection list opens with light exposure. Convention The habit this chapter is teaching, measure then write it on the plan, is the same habit as measuring the yard with a tape instead of pacing it.
2. The bands, on one stated scale
Here is a complication nobody mentions on a plant tag: the published scales disagree with each other.
| Band | NC State Extension (the scale this manual uses) | Oklahoma State Extension (HLA-6440) |
|---|---|---|
| Full sun | At least 6 full hours of direct sunlight | 6 or more hours of direct sunlight each day |
| Part sun or part shade | 3 to 6 hours a day, preferably in morning or early afternoon; the two terms are often used interchangeably | 4 to 6 hours a day |
| Shade | Less than 3 hours of direct sunlight a day, with filtered sunlight the rest of the day | Less than 4 hours of direct sun daily |
A spot reading four hours is part sun on NC State's scale and part sun on Oklahoma State's too, since four is the bottom of their part-sun band. A spot reading three and a half hours is part sun on NC State's and shade on Oklahoma State's. Same yard, same reading, two different answers, and both come from land-grant extension services.
This manual uses NC State Extension's bands and says so every time it names one. Two reasons. It is the scale in the handbook chapter the rest of this process comes from, so the manual is internally consistent. And its wider part-sun band is closer to what plant tags sold in the United States tend to mean, which makes the reading you take more useful at the nursery. Convention Neither scale is more correct than the other. What is not acceptable is mixing them, or writing "part shade" on a sheet without recording which scale you meant, because in six months that word is all you will have.
Notice also what NC State adds that Oklahoma State does not: part sun is 3 to 6 hours "preferably in morning and/or early afternoon." Six hours of morning sun and six hours of late afternoon sun in August are not the same experience for a plant, and the second is harsher. The hours are a count; when they fall is a judgment the count does not capture, which is why the sun sheet has a notes column.
Why the scales differ, and what to do when a tag disagrees with both
Both scales are summaries of a continuum, drawn for different climates. Oklahoma's summers are hotter and its sun more intense than much of NC State's audience experiences, and a four-hour threshold for shade is a defensible line to draw where four hours of afternoon sun does real damage. There is no national standard to appeal to, which is why extension services publish their own.
A plant tag is a third voice, and usually an unsourced one. Tags are printed by growers for national distribution and the band on them is rarely defined. When a tag says "part shade" and your reading says 5 hours, you have two options and the manual recommends the first: buy one plant and watch it for a season before buying eleven more; or find the plant in a regional source, such as your own extension service's plant database or the Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center's state recommended-species lists, where the recommendation is written for a region rather than for a continent. Test it One plant for one season is the cheapest experiment in gardening and it settles arguments that no amount of reading can.
3. The method: four readings and a total
The method costs nothing and takes one clear day.
- Choose the spots. One for each part of the area that might behave differently: each end of a long bed, each side of a yard, anywhere a building or a tree casts into. Mark them with a cane, a brick or a chalk cross so you read the same place each time.
- Pick a clear day, or at least one with clear spells. Overcast days tell you nothing about direct sun, because there is none anywhere.
- Look five times: around 8, 10, 12, 2 and 4. At each spot write yes or no: is the sun on this spot now?
- Total it. Each reading stands for roughly two hours of the day, so five yeses is about ten hours and three is about six. If you watched the shadow move and know the sun arrives at 9.30 and leaves at 1, write the real figure instead; the five readings are a sampling shortcut, not a rule.
- Write the band, naming the scale, and the time of day the sun arrives. Put it on the survey's sun sheet. The sun calculator does the totalling and prints both scales' bands beside each other.
Five readings two hours apart is a sample, and a sample has error. A spot that is in sun from 10.15 to 11.45 reads as "sun at 10, shade at 12" and is credited with two hours when it had an hour and a half. That is accurate enough to choose a band and not accurate enough to argue about a single hour. If a spot lands within half an hour of a band boundary, the honest entry is the band plus a note saying it is borderline, and the decision then rests on the winter reading and on one plant tried for a season.
One clear day in one season is a starting point, not a season's record. Three things can overturn it without warning: the sun's height changes through the year, so a reading taken in June describes June; a deciduous tree changes a spot by two bands between March and July; and a neighbor's new extension, fence or fast-growing conifer can take hours off a bed permanently. Nothing you can do about the third except notice it. The answer to the first two is the dated winter re-check in the next section, and it is the reading that catches the mistake.
4. Summer sun, winter sun, and the re-check
The sun is higher in the sky in summer and lower in winter, and it rises and sets at different points on the horizon through the year. Mississippi State Extension's publication describes the winter pattern plainly: the winter sun rises in the southeast, stays low in the southern sky, and sets in the southwest. Physical principle Its own figure illustrating this is captioned "Solar angles in Mississippi," which is exactly the right caution to carry: the angles depend on latitude, so a diagram drawn for one state is drawn for that state, and the pattern, not the angle, is what transfers.
Two consequences for a reading taken today.
A low winter sun reaches further in and under. A spot shaded all summer by the house or a fence may be lit in winter, when the sun comes in at a shallower angle from further south. That is why winter aconites and snowdrops do well under deciduous trees and why a south-facing wall can be surprisingly warm in February.
A deciduous tree is two different sites in one year. A bed under a maple may get six hours of direct sun in early April and under two in July. On the scale this manual uses, that is full sun and full shade in the same calendar year. Which one you read first decides which plants you buy, and reading only in July is how spring bulbs get left out and shade perennials end up where they will scorch in April.
So the sun sheet gets a second, dated row: a re-check before the leaves come out, and if you can manage it, a third in high summer. NC State Extension's point about assessing winter and summer sun angles is that it tells you where to leave open areas so the winter sun's rays can reach the house and the outdoor living areas; the same assessment tells you where to plant for spring.
If you are reading this in the wrong season to re-check, write the date on the sheet now and let it sit there. A row that says "re-check 2027-03-20, before the maple leafs out" is worth more than an intention.
5. Wind, and the breeze you do not want blocked
Wind gets recorded on the same survey, and it is two separate questions that people collapse into one.
The first is protection. NC State Extension's chapter says that knowing the direction of the prevailing winter wind is crucial for deciding where to put a windbreak, and that this matters especially in the mountains or on the coast. Its method for one is to identify the prevailing winter wind and plant evergreens upwind of the house; one row is effective, and a windbreak of up to five rows with several species is more effective, and it doubles as a privacy screen. A windbreak of native plants also feeds and shelters beneficial insects and birds. Mississippi State Extension's own version places evergreen trees on the north and west sides of the house for winter wind protection, and is explicit that in most areas of Mississippi the winter winds come from the north and northwest. Ask the authority That is Mississippi's prevailing direction. Yours is a question for your own observation and your own extension service, and it is one of the things a year of watching a site answers for free.
The second question is the breeze you want to keep. NC State's chapter is specific that understanding wind patterns also matters so that you do not put structures or plants in the design that block summer breezes from outdoor living spaces. A sitting area on the lee side of a solid fence in August is a still, hot sitting area. The same page recommends using trees to shade the walls of the house rather than the roof, since limbs over the roof shed litter into the gutters and heavy limbs can damage the house in a storm.
Mark both on the drawing with arrows: where the cold wind comes from in winter, and where the pleasant air comes from in summer. Oklahoma State Extension's survey asks the same question in its simplest form, identifying which areas are exposed to strong wind and which are sheltered by buildings, structures or plants.
6. Microclimates: hot walls, cold hollows
Within one small yard there are places measurably hotter, colder, drier and wetter than the average, and they are worth marking because they decide what survives.
Oklahoma State Extension's site evaluation names them directly. Hot spots sit along south-facing walls and near air conditioning units and dryer vents, and areas in full sun or afternoon sun are hotter and drier than shaded ones. Low spots stay wet and get more frost than higher ground. The soil under the roof overhang gets less rain than open ground. Constant airflow near an air conditioning unit dries plantings out.
| Microclimate | Where it is | What it does to planting |
|---|---|---|
| Hot wall | A south or west-facing wall, especially masonry | Hotter and drier; it can carry a plant that is marginal for the zone, and it will cook one that is not adapted |
| Appliance air | Beside an A/C unit or a dryer vent | Constant drying airflow; one of the worst planting positions on a site |
| Rain shadow | Under the roof overhang | Receives far less rain than open ground, year round |
| Frost pocket | A hollow, or ground uphill of a solid fence or wall where cold air pools | More frost than higher ground; later springs and earlier autumns |
| Wind funnel | A gap between two buildings, a side passage | Dries and batters; stakes and ties matter more here |
Oklahoma State Extension's phrasing of the opportunity is worth repeating: skilled gardeners identify microhabitats in the landscape where marginally hardy plants can successfully be grown. Convention That is an argument for noticing them, not a promise that a wall will raise your hardiness zone. Choosing plants that fit the place treats the zone as a filter you do not argue with, and the microclimate as a reason to try one plant rather than eleven.
7. What planting does to the house
Planting changes the building as well as the garden, and two publications put figures on it, both as ceilings.
NC State Extension's chapter says that carefully positioned trees, shrubs and vines can save up to 25% of a typical household's energy consumption for cooling and heating, and immediately pairs it with a warning: over-shading a home may raise energy and maintenance bills, because lights get used more and an air conditioner may be needed to control humidity. Mississippi State Extension's publication says that heating or cooling bills could be reduced by as much as 30 percent with proper placement of plants. Convention Both are ranges with a ceiling and a "can" or "could" in them. Neither is a measured saving on a particular house, neither accounts for your insulation, and no reader should buy a tree on the strength of them. What they do justify is this: where a tree is going in anyway, its position is worth thinking about.
The positioning logic is the seasonal one from section 4. Mississippi State's own checklist asks for trees that allow summer shade and winter sun, and for evergreens placed on the north and west sides for winter wind. A deciduous tree on the side that gets hot afternoon sun shades the wall in leaf and lets the low winter sun through once bare. An evergreen in the same position shades it all year, which is a different and sometimes unwanted decision.
NC State adds a wildfire caveat for anyone in a fire-prone area: create at least a 30-foot defensible space around the house, more on a slope or with particularly flammable surrounding vegetation, do not plant within 5 feet of any structure, and do not store firewood or other flammable material on the side the fire would approach from. Ask the authority If wildfire is a real risk where you live, your state or county's own defensible-space guidance governs, and it overrides every aesthetic suggestion in this manual.
8. See it: three readings See it
Rosalind's strip, Burlington, Vermont. Known: she marked three spots along the 12-foot strip with bricks and read them on a clear Saturday in May. North end: sun at 8, 10 and 12; shade at 2 and 4. Middle: the same. South end, nearest the house: sun at 8 and 10; shade at 12, 2 and 4. Totals: about 6 hours at the north end and middle, about 4 at the south end. Bands, on NC State's scale: full sun at the north end and middle (6 hours is the threshold); part sun at the south end. On Oklahoma State's scale the answers would be the same, since both put full sun at 6 or more and both put 4 hours in part sun. Assumed: that the five-reading total is accurate at the north end, where 6 hours is exactly the band boundary; it is her assumption, and she wrote "borderline" in the notes. Open: what happens in August, when the sun is a little lower by 2 p.m. and the house shadow arrives earlier. Under these assumptions the north end is potentially full sun, and she will treat it as part sun when choosing, which costs her nothing and protects her from a scorched plant. Re-check dated: the third week of March, before anything leafs out.
The Okonkwo back yard, Columbus, Ohio. Known: five spots, read on a clear June Sunday. Under the silver maple: shade at every reading. East of the maple's canopy: sun at 8 and 10, shade from 12. Center of the yard: sun at 10, 12 and 2, shade at 8 and 4. Along the south fence: sun at every reading. The wet strip on the west side: sun at 2 and 4 only. Totals and bands: under the maple, under 2 hours, full shade; east of it about 4 hours, part sun; center about 6, full sun, borderline; south fence about 10, full sun; wet strip about 4, part sun with hot afternoon exposure. Assumed: that the maple's canopy will not grow much over the next three years, which for a healthy 40-year-old silver maple is their assumption and an arborist's question. Open: what the wet strip reads in March, when it also has the worst drainage; the two problems interact and the re-check is dated for the second week of April. What it changed: they had planned a vegetable bed under the maple. Under these assumptions that is not a vegetable bed, and the notes column records Oklahoma State's blunt version of why: a vegetable garden in an area that receives only partial sun gives little fruit at harvest.
Dee's back yard, Providence, Rhode Island. Known: she assumed a shade garden, because the building shades the yard every morning. The readings, taken on a clear Saturday in July at two spots: back wall, shade at 8, 10 and 12, sun at 2 and 4; middle of the yard, shade at 8 and 10, sun at 12, 2 and 4. Totals and bands: about 4 hours at the wall and about 6 in the middle, so part sun and borderline full sun on NC State's scale, which is two bands brighter than she expected. Assumed: nothing; this is why the readings exist. Open: whether the afternoon sun in a brick-walled yard is effectively hotter than the hours suggest, which no count captures and which her notes record as "hot, bright, late." What it changed: her shortlist. Under these assumptions the middle of the yard is a part-sun to full-sun site with harsh afternoon exposure, which is a different list from the shade plants she had been looking at, and a reminder that a yard in shadow at breakfast is not a shade garden.
- Oklahoma State University Extension, Planning the Landscape (HLA-6440, 2017): the other published scale, plus the microclimate list this chapter's table is built on.
- NC State Extension Gardener Handbook, chapter 19: the bands this manual uses, the windbreak method and the 25% energy ceiling.
- Mississippi State University Extension, Home Landscape Design: the winter sun's path, with its solar-angle figure drawn for Mississippi's latitude.
9. Practice: read the light Practice
Minimum: three spots, five readings each, on one clear day, totalled and banded on the sun sheet. Time: about two minutes per look, five times, across one day. Materials: something to mark each spot (a cane, a brick, chalk), a phone for the time and for notes, and the site survey's sun sheet.
- Mark the spots the night before, so you are not deciding where to stand at 8 a.m.
- At each of the five times, walk out and write yes or no per spot. It takes two minutes. Note the sky: clear, broken cloud, overcast.
- Total and band each spot, naming the scale, and add a note on when the sun arrives and leaves.
- Mark the wind arrows on the base plan while you are outside: where the cold comes from, where the summer air comes from.
- Date the re-check on the sheet, for before the deciduous leaves come out.
A phone light meter, and what a reading means
A phone app that reports lux is a reasonable indicator of relative brightness between two spots at the same moment, and a poor instrument for anything else: the sensor is uncalibrated, it sits behind glass, and the number changes with the angle you hold it at. It cannot tell you hours of direct sun, which is what a plant tag is actually asking about. If you want to use one, use it to compare two spots in the same minute, not to produce a figure. Learn Houseplant Care's chapter on measuring light with a phone goes into what a phone reading can and cannot establish; the habit is the same indoors and out, and so are the limits.
Sun-path apps and shadow modeling
Apps that overlay the sun's path on a camera view are good at one thing: showing you where the sun will be at a time of year you cannot currently observe. They are modeling the sun's position, which is predictable, and not the obstructions, which are not. A tree that will be in leaf, a fence that is going up next door and a wall the app cannot see are all invisible to it. Test it Use one to decide when to take your winter reading, then take the reading.
Reading a spot that is not accessible five times
If you work away from home all day, the five readings are hard. Two workable substitutes: read on a weekend day and accept that the weather may be unrepresentative, or photograph the spot from a fixed window at set times with a timer, which records the shadow line even if it cannot tell you whether the sky was clear. Neither is as good as standing there, and both are better than guessing.
10. Your garden Your garden
11. Check your work Check your work
Criteria
- Every spot that will hold plants has a number of hours and a band, not an adjective.
- The scale is named beside the band, every time.
- The date of the reading and the sky condition are recorded.
- A borderline reading is marked borderline rather than rounded into a band.
- One re-check is dated, for before the deciduous leaves come out.
- Wind arrows are on the base plan: winter cold, summer breeze.
- Hot walls, appliance air, the rain shadow under the overhang and any frost pocket are marked.
Worked example
Dee's reading (fictional) is the best of the three, and not because it was thorough. It was two spots and five looks, which is the bare minimum. It is good because it overturned the assumption that produced it: she went out believing she had a shade garden and came back with part sun and borderline full sun. Her sheet names the scale, records the date and sky, and carries a note that no count captures, "hot, bright, late," which is the thing that will decide whether a plant rated for six hours actually tolerates her six hours. The one weakness is that both readings were taken in July, which is the most favorable month; her March re-check is dated and will almost certainly show less. That is the right shape for a reading: a number, a band, a named scale, an honest note, and a dated plan to be proved wrong.
Common mistakes
- Reading on an overcast day. There is no direct sun anywhere, so every spot reads as shade and the exercise is wasted.
- Reading once, at noon. Midday is the one hour almost every spot has sun, and it is the least informative.
- Writing "part shade" without the scale. The word means two different numbers of hours depending on who printed it.
- Reading only in high summer and planting a bed under a deciduous tree for the light it has in July.
- Treating one reading for the whole yard. A small yard can hold three bands.
- Confusing bright with direct. A white-walled courtyard in shadow is bright and has no direct sun.
- Blocking the summer breeze with the screen that solves the winter wind, and then wondering why the terrace is airless.
What is still unresolved
- What the spot reads in winter and early spring: only the dated re-check settles it.
- Whether a plant tag's band means what your reading means: Choosing plants that fit the place, and one plant tried for a season.
- Whether a hot wall will carry a plant that is marginal for your zone: nothing here predicts that, and the zone in Choosing plants that fit the place is the filter that comes first.
- How much shade a tree you plant will cast in fifteen years: its mature spread, which is Drawing the planting plan.
- Whether a neighbor's planned building will take your light: not a question this manual can answer, and worth asking them.