Choosing plants
Choosing and placing plants

Choosing plants that fit the place: mature size, light, soil and zone

The hardiness zone, the measured band, the soil and the drainage checked before anything else, and mature height and spread written down as the number that drives the rest.

Start here Essentials

Choosing plants is a filtering job, and the order of the filters is the whole argument of this chapter. Five plants with their mature sizes written down is enough to plant a bed. Everything marked Go deeper is optional on a first pass.

  1. Look up your hardiness zone on the 2023 USDA map, and write it down (section 2).
  2. Write the band, the soil and the drainage from your own survey, in one line (section 3, section 4).
  3. Shortlist five plants that match all four, and no more than five for a first bed (section 7).
  4. Record each one's mature height and spread on the plant list. A plant without those numbers can be neither drawn nor counted (section 5).

Minimum time: about an hour, most of it looking plants up. Done when: five plants are on the plant list with mature height and spread filled in.

1. The order of the questions Understand

Most people choose plants by looking at them, then find out afterward whether they will grow. This chapter inverts that, and the inversion is the only idea in it.

The order is: zone, then light, then soil and water, then mature size, then everything else. The first four are filters that reject candidates. The rest, which is to say color, season, texture, scent and your own taste, operates only on what survives the filters.

This is not a counsel of joylessness. It is a way of making the enjoyable part count for something. A shortlist of twenty plants you like, of which three can live where you are putting them, is twenty decisions you will have to make again in a nursery car park. A shortlist of eight that all pass the filters is a list you can choose from on taste alone, which is the pleasant way round.

UF/IFAS Extension describes the same discipline as the guiding principle of planting design: "right plant, right place," meaning to select plants that can thrive in the growing conditions of the site and then locate them for both visual appeal and health. Convention Its own method for building a master plant list puts the site conditions first and the visual characteristics second, explicitly: once growing requirements are satisfied, consider the visual characteristics as you create the list.

2. The hardiness zone, and what it does not tell you

The USDA Plant Hardiness Zone Map is the standard reference in the United States, and the current edition is the 2023 map, which replaced the 2012 one. It is based on the average annual extreme minimum winter temperature, divided into 10-degree Fahrenheit zones and 5-degree half zones, which is what the a and b suffixes mean. Zone 5a and zone 5b are 5 degrees apart.

Find yours at the USDA Agricultural Research Service's interactive map by zip code, and write it on your setup and on the plant list. Convention When you name a zone anywhere, name the edition too, because a plant described as hardy to zone 6 in a book printed before 2024 was using the older map, and some places changed.

What a zone tells you: roughly how cold it gets, on average, in the coldest part of a normal winter.

What a zone does not tell you, and this list is longer:

  • Summer heat. Zone 7 in coastal Washington and zone 7 in Georgia share a winter minimum and nothing else. Many plants fail in the south from summer heat rather than winter cold.
  • Humidity, which decides a great deal of disease pressure.
  • Drought, and when it falls. A Mediterranean-type climate with a dry summer is a different problem from a continental one with dry winters.
  • Soil. The map knows nothing about your clay, your pH or the subsoil the builders left.
  • Your own microclimates, the hot wall and the frost pocket from Sun, shade and wind.
  • Extremes. It is an average of annual minima, so a once-a-decade cold snap is colder than your zone.

So the zone is a filter rather than an answer: it tells you what is out, not what is in. NC State Extension's framing is that a plant's designated hardiness zone is a starting point for understanding its environmental requirements, with plant tags providing further information and, for the most accurate guidance, research-based regional sources. Convention A regional plant list from your own extension service or a regional botanical institution is worth more than a national database, because it has already applied the filters the map leaves out.

3. The measured band, against the tag's band

You measured the light in Sun, shade and wind and wrote a band on the survey's sun sheet, naming the scale. This is where that number earns its keep.

The bands this manual uses are NC State Extension's: full sun is at least 6 full hours of direct sunlight; part sun or part shade, terms often used interchangeably, is 3 to 6 hours a day, preferably in morning or early afternoon; full shade is less than 3 hours of direct sunlight a day with filtered sunlight the rest of the day.

A plant tag also carries a band, usually as a small icon. The problem is that nobody tells you what the tag means by it. Tags are printed by growers for national distribution, the band is rarely defined, and the two published extension scales already disagree about what part sun means. So a tag reading "part shade" and a yard reading 4 hours are two claims that may or may not be about the same thing.

What to do with that, in order of reliability:

  1. Prefer a regional source over the tag. Your extension service's plant database, or a regional recommended-species list such as the Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center's state collections, has usually made the judgment for your region.
  2. Treat a borderline reading conservatively. If your spot is at 6 hours and a plant wants full sun, it will probably do; if your spot is at 6 hours and a plant wants shade, it will probably scorch. The cost of being wrong is asymmetric, and the shade side is the expensive one.
  3. Buy one, not eleven. Test it One plant for one season settles what no amount of reading can, for the price of one plant.

Write the band you measured into the plant list's own column, so that when you are standing in a nursery in April the number is on your phone and not in your memory.

4. Soil, drainage and the wet corner

The third filter is the one from Soil and Water, drainage and slope: texture, pH and the measured drainage rate.

Three practical ways this filter bites.

pH. Clemson Cooperative Extension's bands are vegetables, most turfgrasses and most ornamentals at 6.0 to 6.5, most ornamental plants at 5.8 to 6.5 in its tree-planting publication, and azaleas, rhododendrons, blueberries and conifers at 5.0 to 5.5. If your test came back at 7.4 and you want blueberries, the honest conclusion is a container with its own soil, not a campaign against the ground.

Drainage. A spot that failed the 48-hour test is a wet site, and wet-site plants are a real category rather than a consolation prize. A spot that drained at 2.5 inches an hour is a dry site in a hot week, whatever the rainfall average says.

Where the two conflict. A clay soil that holds water in winter and bakes hard in summer is the commonest difficult site in American gardens, and the plants that handle it are a narrower list than either "wet" or "dry" suggests. This is the case where a regional source earns its fee, because your extension service knows which plants cope with your particular version of it.

Note the filter order matters here too. Soil can be worked with: a raised bed puts root run above the problem, as Soil sets out. The zone is fixed, and the light changes only if you remove something. That is why zone and light come first.

5. Mature size, the number everything rests on

If you take one thing from this manual, take this: record the mature height and spread of every plant you are considering, before you decide anything else about it.

Every calculation later in this manual uses mature spread. The plant count in the plant count calculator divides bed area by the square of it. The circles in Drawing the planting plan are drawn at it. The distance from a wall is derived from it. The site plan reads it off the plant list. A row on the plant list without a spread in it is a plant you have no way to place.

UF/IFAS Extension's convention is the foundation: a plant is drawn on a planting plan as a circle at its mature spread at the plan's scale, and spacing written as "2' o.c." means plants with a 2-foot mature spread set 2 feet apart center to center, so that they touch at mature size. Convention Mississippi State Extension gives the same relationship from the drawing side: at a scale of 1 inch = 10 feet, a plant with a mature size of about 5 feet is drawn with a circle half an inch across.

Three published figures follow from mature size, and they are the ones that prevent the classic mistakes.

RuleThe figurePublished byWorked
Distance from a buildingHalf the mature width, plus at least 1 footNC State ExtensionA shrub 5 feet wide at maturity sits 3 1/2 feet out from the wall
Height of a corner plantingNot higher than two-thirds of the height of the eaves, though the publication adds this is not a hard and fast ruleAlabama ExtensionEaves at 9 feet means a corner planting up to about 6
Tree positionSmall-canopy trees near the house, taller ones further backNC State ExtensionA 40-foot canopy does not belong 8 feet from a wall

Alabama Extension adds a caution about roots that is easy to forget on a small lot: trees and shrubs should not be planted where their roots will interfere with water and sewer lines. That is a reason to have the marked lines from Measuring and drawing your site on the drawing when you are placing plants and not only when you are digging.

Limits

Published mature sizes vary, sometimes by a lot, between sources: a nursery tag, a national database and your own extension service can give three different figures for the same species, because mature size depends on climate, soil, water and how long "mature" means. None of them is lying. When sources disagree, prefer the regional one, and when you are placing a plant near a building or a boundary, use the largest figure you found rather than the most convenient. A plant that stays smaller than planned is a minor disappointment; one that gets larger is a chainsaw.

6. The layers of a planting

A planting that works usually has several heights in it, and naming the layers makes it easier to notice which one is missing.

LayerRoughlyWhat it does
CanopyLarge treesShade, structure, the thing that changes the site's own conditions
UnderstorySmall trees and large shrubsScreening at eye level, scale between a house and a lawn
ShrubShrubsMass, year-round bulk, the backbone of a border
PerennialHerbaceous plantsSeason, flower, change through the year
Ground layerLow spreading plants and bulbsCovers soil, suppresses weeds, fills the gaps between everything else

In a small garden you will not have all five, and the one most often missing is the ground layer, which is why so many beds are mulch with plants standing in it. The one most often overdone is the shrub layer, because shrubs are what garden centers sell most of.

Alabama Extension gives a proportion figure for the mix of effects that is worth having and worth attributing: use 80 to 90 percent of the plants for foliage effect, with some variety in foliage color, green providing the continuity and the backdrop, and color used to focus attention on an area and complement the house. Convention It is one publication's rule rather than a measured finding, and as a corrective to a bed designed entirely from flower photographs it is a good one.

The same publication is the source of the screening figure from Beds, lawn and use areas: a screen needs to be at least 6 feet high to be effective, evergreens are an important part of a screen, and deciduous plants should be added for variety in color and texture rather than planting evergreens alone.

7. Reading a plant tag and a nursery's claims

A plant tag is marketing with some facts on it. Read it in this order.

  • The botanical name. This is the only unambiguous identifier on the tag. Common names are regional and reused: several unrelated plants are called "lily," and a "cedar" in one part of the country is a different genus from a "cedar" in another. Write the botanical name on the plant list, because it is what a nursery can quote from and what a database can be searched on.
  • The cultivar name, in single quotes after the species. This matters for size more than anything else: a cultivar may be a quarter the size of the species, which changes every calculation downstream. It also matters for the nativar question in Native plants and pollinators.
  • The mature size, which is the number you came for, and which is frequently optimistic about how long "mature" takes.
  • The light band, compared with your measured hours rather than with an impression.
  • The zone range, compared with your 2023 zone.
  • The pot size, which tells you what you are paying for now and nothing about the plant's future.

What a tag does not tell you: whether the plant is invasive where you live, what it feeds, how it behaves in your soil, or whether the nursery's region is yours. Product-specific A nursery stocks what sells in its trading area, which is not the same as what suits your yard: a chain store's spring delivery is planned regionally or nationally, and the plants on the bench in April are the ones that look good in April.

Three questions worth asking a nursery that is worth buying from, and the answers tell you a good deal about the nursery:

  1. How big does this actually get here, after ten years? A good answer is a number with a caveat. A bad answer is the tag read back to you.
  2. Where was this grown? Relevant for hardiness and, for native plants, for provenance; Native plants and pollinators covers why.
  3. Is this on the state's invasive or noxious list? A nursery that knows the answer is a nursery that has looked.

8. Invasive species, which is a regional question

An invasive plant is one that spreads beyond where it was planted and causes harm, and the critical word is regional: a plant that is a well-behaved garden shrub in one state is a landscape-scale problem in another.

The route to the answer is the USDA National Agricultural Library's National Invasive Species Information Center, whose terrestrial plants page links to federal and state noxious-weed lists. Ask the authority Your own state's list is the one that governs, and this manual names no species nationally, because a list that is right in Florida is wrong in Vermont.

Check a candidate before you buy it, not after. Being sold a plant is not evidence that it is legal or wise to plant it where you live: state regulation of the nursery trade varies and lists change.

When a plant you wanted turns out to be invasive where you are, the useful pattern is substitution rather than abandonment, and extension services publish lists in exactly that form. UF/IFAS Extension's alternatives to invasive plants commonly found in south Florida landscapes is the model: it lists each invasive plant and names non-invasive plants that are similar in size, habit, texture and flower color, limited to plants generally available in the nursery trade. That publication is explicitly south Florida's and is cited here as a pattern to look for in your own region rather than as a list to use. Its original publication date is September 2013, revised August 2018 and October 2026.

9. Keep, move or remove what is already there

Existing plants get the same filters applied to them, and the judgment goes on the survey's features sheet with a reason.

NC State Extension's basis for the judgment is health, mature size and what the plant contributes. Oklahoma State Extension's survey asks you to identify plants you want to retain and work into the new planting, to look for plants that have overgrown their space, such as a shrub overhanging the sidewalk or blocking a window, and notes that some trees and shrubs need only pruning while others need removing or transplanting. It also says plainly that dead or dying trees may pose hazards and require removal.

VerdictWhenWhat it costs
KeepHealthy, right size for the place, contributes somethingNothing, and it is usually the largest asset on the site
PruneRight plant, wrong shape, and the pruning is within your competenceAn afternoon; for a mature tree, an arborist
MoveRight plant, wrong place, small enough to lift and early enough in its lifeA season of setback and the risk of losing it
RemoveWrong for the site, overgrown past recovery, or invasiveWork, and the gap it leaves, which is also an opportunity
AskA mature tree, anything protected by an ordinance, anything on a boundaryA phone call, and it is cheaper than the alternative
Caution

Whether a mature tree is sound, and whether it can be kept near work you are planning, is a question for a certified arborist and not for this manual. The same goes for pruning one. Tree failures injure people, and a tree that has been damaged at the roots by excavation can fail years later. If a tree is near anything you are building, get it assessed before the work rather than after, and tell the contractor where its roots are.

10. See it: two shortlists See it

Fictional example

Rosalind's strip, Burlington, Vermont. Known, from her own survey: zone 5a on the 2023 map; north end and middle about 6 hours of direct sun, borderline full sun, which she is treating as part sun; south end about 4 hours, part sun; sandy free-draining fill, pH 6.8, drainage 2.5 inches an hour; the marked gas line and its no-dig zone down the middle of a 4-foot strip; goal, pollinators and a planting that looks deliberate from the sidewalk. Her filters, in order: zone 5a or colder; part sun; dry, free-draining; and nothing whose mature spread exceeds about 3 feet, because the usable ground either side of the no-dig zone is narrow. Assumed: that a plant rated for zones 3 to 8 is safe at 5a, which is sound, and that the borderline 6-hour reading will hold in August, which is hers and is why she filtered for part sun rather than full. Open: which of her candidates are native to her ecoregion and what each feeds, which Native plants and pollinators settles. What she has: five rows on the plant list, each with a botanical name, a mature height and a mature width in feet, and the inches column filling itself. The spreads she recorded run from 1 1/2 to 3 feet, which is the information Drawing the planting plan needs and which, when she gets there, will tell her she can fit far fewer than she hoped.

Fictional example

Harlan's front yard, Austin, Texas. Known: zone 8b; full afternoon sun; watering permitted two days a week; an HOA that approves plans and requires a "maintained" appearance; the work hired out. His filters: zone 8b; full sun with hard afternoon exposure; whatever his soil test says; tolerant of a two-day watering regime once established; and nothing on Texas's invasive list. Assumed: that "established" means the same thing under a watering restriction as it does in the publications, which it does not: establishment watering is a separate question from a mature plant's water needs, and Planting and the first three years is where it gets resolved. He noted it as an assumption and as a question for his water utility, because whether new plantings are exempt from a restriction is their answer and nobody else's. Open: what the HOA will approve. What it changed: he asked the contractor for mature height and spread for every plant in the proposal, in writing, before signing anything. Two of the proposed plants turned out to reach 12 feet across in his climate, in beds 5 feet deep. Under these assumptions those two were replaced, and the question that caught it was not about appearance or price.

11. Practice: shortlist five plants Practice

Minimum: five plants on the list, each passing all four filters, each with mature height and spread. Time: about an hour. Materials: your survey, the plant list, and a regional plant source: your extension service's database, a state recommended-species list, or a local nursery that will answer questions.

  1. Write your four filters as one line at the top: zone, band, soil and drainage. "5a, part sun, sandy and free-draining, pH 6.8."
  2. Find candidates from a regional source, not from a national search. Twenty is plenty to start with.
  3. Reject on the filters, fast, and put the rejects on the rejected sheet with the reason, because the same plant will tempt you again in April.
  4. Look up mature height and spread for each survivor in at least two places, and when they disagree, record the larger figure and note the disagreement.
  5. Check each one against your state's invasive list, and against a deer list if deer are a constraint.
  6. Keep the best five, and leave the rest on the list for when a later phase needs them.
Go deeper

When three sources give three mature sizes

This is normal and it is not evidence of carelessness. Mature size is a function of climate, soil, water and how long you wait; a species that reaches 15 feet in the southeast may stop at 8 in the upper midwest. Rank your sources: your own extension service first, then a regional botanical institution, then a national database, then a tag. Record the largest credible figure where the plant is near a building or a boundary, and the regional figure where you are counting plants for a bed.

Deer, and what a rating means

Rutgers' landscape plants rated by deer resistance is one of the better-known lists and its own framing is the thing to carry: ratings describe how often a plant is damaged, not whether it can be. Convention Deer pressure is local and seasonal, and a hard winter changes what gets eaten. Treat a rating as an ordering of likelihood, not as a guarantee, and if deer are a serious constraint, ask neighbors what actually survives on your street, which is better evidence than any list.

Designing under a water restriction

Where water is restricted, the US EPA's WaterSense program publishes regional landscaping tip sheets for the northeast, midwest, southeast, northwest, west and southwest, which is the right scale for advice of this kind. Two things to keep separate: the water a mature planting needs, which is a design decision, and the water a new planting needs to establish, which is a fixed cost in the first years and applies to drought-tolerant and native plants too. Ask the authority Whether newly planted material is exempt from a restriction, and for how long, is set by your water utility.

Plants under power lines and over septic fields

Two places where the plant list is decided for you. Under overhead lines, mature height is the filter and the utility usually publishes what it will tolerate and what it will cut. Over a septic field, woody roots are the problem and the person who services the system is the person to ask. Both belong on the survey's questions sheet rather than in a plant database.

12. Your garden Your garden

13. Check your work Check your work

Criteria

  • Your zone is written down, with the map edition named.
  • The band on each plant row names the scale it came from.
  • Every candidate has a mature height and a mature width in feet, from a source you can name.
  • Where sources disagreed on size, the larger figure is recorded and the disagreement is noted.
  • Every candidate has been checked against your state's invasive or noxious list.
  • Botanical names are on the list, not just common names.
  • Rejected plants are on the rejected sheet with the reason.
  • Existing plants have a verdict with a reason, and anything about a mature tree is marked as an arborist's question.

Worked example

Harlan's list (fictional) is the instructive one, because he is hiring and did the work anyway. Asking the contractor for mature height and spread in writing for every proposed plant is the single most useful thing a client can do in a planting proposal, and it caught two plants that would reach 12 feet across in 5-foot beds. Neither price nor appearance would have caught it. His open question is also handled well: he noticed that "drought tolerant" and "establishes without much water" are different claims, wrote it down as an assumption rather than resolving it himself, and sent the watering-restriction question to the water utility, which is the only body that can answer it. What his list still lacks is the invasive check, which in Texas is his own to make and which a proposal from a contractor does not substitute for.

Common mistakes

  • Choosing by appearance and checking conditions afterward, which is the whole thing this chapter inverts.
  • Treating the zone as the only filter, and planting something that is hardy and hates your summers.
  • Using a pre-2024 zone without noticing which map it came from.
  • Trusting a tag's light icon against a measured band without asking what the tag means.
  • Recording the pot size instead of the mature size.
  • Recording a common name only, and buying a different plant in April.
  • Missing a cultivar's size, which can be a quarter of the species'.
  • Skipping the invasive check because the plant was for sale locally.
  • Treating a deer-resistance rating as immunity.
  • Judging a mature tree's health yourself.

What is still unresolved

  • Whether a candidate is native to your region, and what it feeds: Native plants and pollinators.
  • How many of each you actually need: Drawing the planting plan and the plant count calculator, and the number will be smaller than the list suggests.
  • Whether a mature tree is sound: a certified arborist.
  • What your state's invasive list says: your state, and it changes.
  • Whether a watering restriction exempts new planting: your water utility.
  • What will be approved, where an HOA or a landlord is involved: them, in writing.

14. Knowledge check and scenario

Why does the hardiness zone come first, and why is it not enough on its own?
It comes first because it is the filter you cannot work around: you cannot change your winter minimum, while you can raise a bed or improve soil. It is not enough because it is based on average annual extreme minimum winter temperature and nothing else, so it knows nothing about summer heat, humidity, drought, soil or your microclimates. Two places in the same zone can be quite different gardens.
What does "2' o.c." mean, and where does the convention come from?
UF/IFAS Extension: plants with a 2-foot mature spread set 2 feet apart, center to center, so that they just touch at mature size. The convention is the reason mature spread is the number everything else rests on, and it is the arithmetic behind the plant count in Drawing the planting plan.
How far from a wall does a shrub with a 5-foot mature spread go, and why?
NC State Extension's rule is half the mature width plus at least a foot, so 3 1/2 feet out from the structure. The reason is that the plant will eventually occupy that full width, and a plant pressed against siding is a maintenance problem, an air-circulation problem and, in time, a pruning commitment forever. It also means a foundation bed 3 feet deep has no room for that shrub.
Three sources give three different mature sizes for the same shrub. What do you record?
Prefer the regional source, record the disagreement, and where the plant is near a building or a boundary use the largest credible figure. Sources differ because mature size depends on climate, soil and water, not because somebody is wrong. A plant that stays smaller than planned is a disappointment; one that grows larger is a chainsaw.
Why is a plant being on sale at a local nursery not evidence that it is a good idea?
Because a nursery stocks what sells in its trading area, which is planned regionally or nationally and keyed to what looks good on the bench that month. It is not a judgment about your yard, and it is not a check against your state's invasive list. Regulation of what may be sold varies by state and lists change, so the check is yours to make.
(Go deeper) What is the difference between a drought-tolerant plant and a plant that needs no water?
Establishment. A drought-tolerant plant, native plants included, still needs regular water while its roots grow into the surrounding soil, which takes seasons for a perennial and years for a tree. The water a mature planting needs is a design question; the water a new planting needs is a fixed cost in the early years. Planting and the first three years has the schedule, and under a watering restriction the exemption question goes to your water utility.
Scenario: at a nursery you find a shrub you love. The tag says "part shade, 3 to 4 feet, zones 5 to 9." Your bed reads 5 hours of direct sun, you are in zone 6a, and the bed is 3 feet deep against a fence.
Three things are being assumed. The tag's "part shade" is undefined and your 5 hours is part sun on NC State Extension's scale and close to its upper boundary, so this plant may be in more sun than it wants. The 3-to-4-foot figure is a tag's figure and may be smaller than it grows in your region. And a 4-foot-wide plant in a 3-foot bed overhangs both edges, and against a fence the usable depth is even less. Buying three multiplies all three assumptions.
This is the strongest path and it costs one plant. The regional source settles the size question that the tag cannot, the invasive check is yours to make regardless of what is for sale, and one plant for one season settles the light question that two published scales already disagree about. If it thrives, you buy the rest with evidence and you will know by then how wide it really gets. What it leaves open is whether the bed should be deeper, which is a question for Beds, lawn and use areas rather than for the plant.
The arithmetic is right and the conclusion may be premature. If the regional figure turns out to be 2 1/2 feet here, it fits; if it is 5 feet, you were right. The reject is also worth recording with its reason on the rejected sheet, because this plant will be on the bench again next April and you will have forgotten why you walked away.

Checklist

Records your learning only; it is not a qualification.