Water, drainage and slope: where it goes now and where it should go
Drainage measured with a hole and a bucket, roof runoff traced from each downspout, slope measured as a percentage, and the point named where this becomes somebody else's job.
- Start here: the essentials
- 1. Walk the lot after rain
- 2. The drainage test: a hole, water and a clock
- 3. Roof runoff, which is usually the real problem
- 4. Measuring slope, and the thresholds it decides
- 5. What to do about water, in order of cost
- 6. Rain gardens, and whose setbacks
- 7. Where your water becomes somebody else's
- 8. See it: two wet yards
- 9. Practice: dig one hole and measure one slope
- 10. Your garden
- 11. Check your work
- 12. Knowledge check and scenario
Start here Essentials
Most "my yard is wet" problems are one of three things: a downspout, compaction, or a low spot that is doing what low spots do. One hole and one walk tell you which. Everything marked Go deeper is optional on a first pass.
- Dig one wide hole about 10 inches deep where you intend to plant, fill it with water and let it drain once (section 2).
- Fill it again and time the drop. Two readings and the hours between them is the whole measurement (section 2).
- Follow each downspout and write down where its water actually goes (section 3).
- Measure the slope of anything you walk on or plan to build on, as a percentage (section 4).
Minimum time: about 30 minutes of work spread over a few hours of waiting. Done when: you have an inches-per-hour figure and a yes or no on the 48-hour question for at least one spot, on the survey's soil sheet.
1. Walk the lot after rain Understand
The single best piece of site information about water is free, and most people have already half-collected it without writing it down: where does water stand, and for how long?
NC State Extension's site-survey step asks for exactly this, and Oklahoma State Extension's asks you to identify areas where water collects, noting that low spots and areas around downspouts tend to be wet and other areas may be exceptionally dry. The method is to walk out after rain, twice: once while it is still raining or just after, and again a day or two later. The first walk shows you where water goes. The second shows you where it stays, which is the one that matters.
Write on the base plan, with a date and how much rain it was if you know:
- Where water runs, as arrows. Across the drive, along the fence, off the patio toward the house.
- Where it stands during rain, as a shaded blob.
- Where it is still standing two days later, as a second, usually much smaller, blob. This is the one that kills plants.
- Where the ground is dry when everything else is wet: under the overhang, beside the A/C unit, at the top of a slope.
- Where erosion is happening: bare channels, exposed roots, silt fanning out at the bottom of a slope.
Two days is a threshold rather than a feeling, and it comes from the next section. Physical principle Roots need air as well as water. Soil that stays saturated has no air in its pore spaces, and roots of most garden plants die in it, which is why a plant in a wet spot often looks exactly like a plant that has been underwatered: in both cases the roots have stopped working.
2. The drainage test: a hole, water and a clock
This manual adapts the test University of Minnesota Extension publishes for siting a rain garden, because it is the clearest published home method and because its criterion is a number rather than an impression.
Minnesota's method: dig a wide hole 10 inches deep and fill it with water. Their criterion: the soil must soak up the water within 48 hours, both to keep plants alive and to keep mosquitoes from breeding.
The full version, which gives you a rate rather than a pass or fail:
- Dig a wide hole about 10 inches deep where you plan to plant. Wide matters: a narrow post hole drains mostly sideways and flatters the result.
- Fill it with water and let it drain away completely. This pre-wets the surrounding soil, which otherwise soaks up the first fill like a sponge and gives you a reading that is far too fast.
- Fill it again, and measure the water depth from the bottom of the hole. Write it down with the time.
- Come back after a measured interval, an hour is convenient, and measure again. Write the depth and the time.
- Work out the rate: the drop in inches divided by the hours. The drainage calculator does it, and also projects how long the hole takes to empty and whether that clears 48 hours.
What the number means, roughly:
| Rate | Reads as | What it suggests |
|---|---|---|
| 2 inches an hour or more | Fast | Likely sandy or gravelly; it will need watering more often than the rest of the yard, especially through establishment |
| About 0.5 to 2 inches an hour | Moderate | The middle of the range most plants are sold for |
| Under 0.5 inches an hour | Slow | Likely clay, compaction or both; check for a hard layer as in Soil |
| No measurable drop | Not draining | Plant what tolerates standing water, or treat it as a drainage job rather than a planting one |
The projection to empty assumes the rate holds all the way down, which real holes often do not: they slow as the surrounding soil saturates. Test it Treat the projected time as the optimistic end, and if a spot is close to the 48-hour line, the honest answer is to fill the hole and come back in two days rather than trusting the arithmetic.
One hole describes one spot, on one day, at one soil moisture. A test done in August after three dry weeks will read faster than the same hole in April. It tells you nothing about what happens when the water table is high, nothing about where the water goes once it has left the hole, and nothing about whether water is arriving from somewhere else. Dig a hole wherever you intend a bed, rather than extrapolating one reading across a yard, and treat a single fast reading in a dry month with suspicion.
3. Roof runoff, which is usually the real problem
Before deciding that your ground drains badly, find out how much water is being delivered to it, because the answer is usually more than people imagine.
NC State Extension gives the figure: a 1,000-square-foot roof produces 630 gallons of runoff in a 1-inch rainstorm. Physical principle That is arithmetic about area and volume rather than a claim about any particular house, and it scales: half that roof in the same storm delivers about 315 gallons, and two inches of rain doubles it. All of it arrives at a handful of points, which are the downspouts.
So a wet patch six feet from a downspout is usually not a soil problem. It is 600 gallons being poured onto one spot several times a year, and no amount of soil improvement will absorb it.
What to record, per downspout:
- Where it discharges: onto a splash block, into a pipe, into the ground, onto the drive.
- Where the water goes from there, traced on the ground after rain.
- Roughly what area of roof feeds it. Pacing the roof plan is good enough.
- Whether it is discharging toward the house, which is a problem for the building before it is a problem for the garden.
The cheapest fixes in this entire manual live here: an extension on a downspout that moves the discharge ten feet away from a bed, or a splash block aimed differently, can resolve a "drainage problem" for the cost of a part. NC State Extension also treats rain barrels and cisterns as a water-conservation measure in the same breath, which is a second use for the same water, and a barrel that overflows in a storm still needs somewhere for the overflow to go.
4. Measuring slope, and the thresholds it decides
Slope is expressed as a percentage: the rise divided by the run, times 100. A 6-inch fall over 10 feet is 6 divided by 120, which is 5 percent.
Measuring it takes a straight board, a level and a tape:
- Put one end of the board on the high point and hold the other end out toward the low point.
- Level the board with the spirit level resting on it.
- Measure straight down from the underside of the free end to the ground. That is the rise.
- Measure the board's length, which is the run. Divide, multiply by 100.
- For a long slope, do it in board-length steps and add the rises, keeping the board level each time.
The slope calculator does the arithmetic and compares the result with the published thresholds. Those thresholds all come from one source, University of Wisconsin-Madison Extension's Landscape Structures, and they are the figures that decide what you can build:
| Surface | Published figure | What it decides |
|---|---|---|
| Walk or path | 1 to 4 percent ideal; no more than 6 percent for safety | Whether a path works as a path |
| Any ground you walk on | Install steps where the ground slopes more than 6 percent | Whether steps are needed |
| Driveway | At least 1 percent (1 foot in 100) to drain; no more than 10 percent, which is hazardous in winter | Whether a drive is usable and drains |
| Patio | 1 to 2 percent, falling away from the house | Whether water sits on it or runs off it, and which way |
Two things worth saying about this table. First, every figure in it is from one publication, which is why it is attributed in one place rather than spread around as general knowledge. Convention Second, the patio figure is the one that catches do-it-yourself builders: a patio laid dead level holds water, and a patio sloped the wrong way delivers it to the house wall. One to two percent is about a quarter of an inch per foot, which is less than it sounds and more than you will achieve by eye.
Where the ground slopes more than 6 percent and you want to walk on it, you need steps, and Paths, patios and structures covers the published rule for sizing them. The slope calculator will work out a riser and tread for you from the same rule.
5. What to do about water, in order of cost
Once you know the rate, the roof contribution and the slope, the options sort themselves roughly by cost and reversibility. Work down this list and stop when something solves it.
| Option | What it suits | Cost and reversibility |
|---|---|---|
| Move the downspout discharge | A wet patch near a downspout | Cheapest thing here; fully reversible |
| Plant what tolerates it | A spot that stays wet but not permanently waterlogged | Costs the plants; the honest answer more often than people like |
| Raise the bed above the problem | Beds on slow or compacted ground | Clemson Extension's 8 to 12 inches of native soil; moderate work, no excavation |
| Aerate and add topsoil | An area compacted by construction | Wisconsin Extension suggests at least 4 to 6 inches of topsoil over aerated ground; a whole-area job |
| A rain garden | A place that collects water and does drain within 48 hours | Real work; setbacks apply; see the next section |
| A dry creek or swale | Moving surface water along a route you choose | Changes where water goes, which is the point at which the questions start |
| French drain, dry well, regrading | Ground that will not drain and water that must be moved | Generally a contractor; may need permission; see section 7 |
The second row deserves defending, because it is the one people skip. A spot that holds water for a day after rain is not a defect to be engineered away; it is a condition, and there are plants that prefer it. Designing with the wet spot rather than against it is the cheapest, most reliable and most reversible of these options, and it is the only one on the list that gets better rather than worse with time.
6. Rain gardens, and whose setbacks
A rain garden is a shallow planted depression that collects runoff, usually from a roof or a drive, and lets it soak in rather than running off the lot. University of Minnesota Extension publishes a homeowner method for building one, and the US EPA publishes homeowner guidance on them as part of its Soak Up the Rain program.
Minnesota's figures, given as Minnesota's:
- Typical size: 100 to 300 square feet.
- The drainage requirement: the soil must soak up the water within 48 hours, which is the same criterion as the hole test above. A spot that fails that test is not a rain garden site.
- Setbacks: at least 10 feet from buildings; 35 feet or more from a septic drain field; at least 150 feet from a drinking water well where fertilizers or pesticides will be used, which Minnesota attributes to its Department of Health for agricultural chemicals; and a minimum of 20 feet between a well and drainage features such as French drains under Minnesota Rule 4725.4450, rising to 40 feet for sensitive wells.
Ask the authority Those numbers are Minnesota's, and that is the whole point of printing them with the state's name attached. A setback is a rule somebody has authority over, and the somebody who has authority over your yard is your own state and county, not Minnesota. The figures above are here so you know what kind of thing to ask about: distance from buildings, from septic systems, from wells, from property lines. Ask your county's stormwater or environmental health office what the figures are where you live, and write the answers on the survey's questions sheet with who said them.
Where a rain garden is a good idea, it is a genuinely good idea: it handles roof water on site, it is a planting rather than a structure, and it is well suited to the kind of small, awkward, wet corner that is otherwise a nuisance. Where the ground fails the 48-hour test, it is a pond, and that is a different project with different rules.
Sizing one, roughly
The sizing question is how much water arrives against how much the garden can hold and infiltrate. The arriving volume comes from the roof or paved area feeding it, which is the 630-gallons-per-1,000-square-feet-per-inch figure from section 3. Minnesota's typical range of 100 to 300 square feet is a useful sanity check: if your arithmetic says you need 800 square feet of rain garden in a 400-square-foot yard, the honest conclusion is that this is not the tool for the job and the answer lies upstream, in where the roof water is being sent.
Permeable paving as a runoff decision
NC State Extension treats permeable paving as a water-conservation and runoff measure, and that is the frame worth using: the question is not whether gravel looks better than concrete but how many square feet of your lot shed water rather than absorb it. A permeable surface is one of the few hardscape choices that reduces the problem instead of moving it. The materials table carries permeability as one of the columns you can filter on.
Water-restricted regions
Where water is restricted, drainage and irrigation are the same conversation from two ends. The US EPA's WaterSense program publishes regional landscaping tip sheets for the northeast, midwest, southeast, northwest, west and southwest, which is the right scale for advice of this kind. Ask the authority What is actually permitted, including whether newly planted material is exempt from a restriction and for how long, is set by your water utility and nobody else.
7. Where your water becomes somebody else's
This is the boundary of the chapter and of the manual.
University of Wisconsin-Madison Extension states that ground elevation must match the neighbors' at lot lines. That single sentence is the design constraint and the legal one at the same time. Everything you do inside your boundary that changes the volume, the speed or the direction of water leaving it arrives somewhere, and the somewhere is usually downhill and usually belongs to somebody else.
Regrading toward a neighbor's lot, toward your own foundation, or toward a public drain is not a gardening decision. It can be a liability, it may require permission, and it can damage a building in ways that take years to show. If a solution to your water problem involves changing where water leaves your property, stop and get a drainage contractor or a civil engineer, and ask your local building or stormwater office what is permitted. This manual designs plantings; it does not design drainage.
The practical test for whether you have crossed the line: if the fix works by sending water somewhere else rather than by absorbing, slowing or planting it, it is in contractor territory. A rain garden absorbs. A raised bed sidesteps. A downspout extension moves water ten feet within your own lot, which is usually fine and is worth checking if the ten feet takes it to a boundary. A swale cut to drain your low corner into the neighbor's hedge moves the problem to a person.
The same logic runs in reverse, and it is worth saying because it is the commonest version of this problem: if water is arriving on your lot from uphill, from a neighbor's downspout or from a road, you have a conversation rather than an engineering project, at least to begin with. Learn Conflict Management's chapter on neighbors, landlords and people you hired is a better starting point than a trench.
8. See it: two wet yards See it
The Okonkwo back yard, Columbus, Ohio. Known: water stands for two days after rain along the west side, where a sewer line was dug in 2024. They walked it the morning after a storm and again two days later; the second blob was about 12 feet by 5. The hole test in the middle of the wet strip: filled, drained once over several hours, refilled to 9 inches, and after one hour it stood at 8.6 inches. Rate: 0.4 inches an hour. Projection: about 21 hours to empty from 8.6 inches if the rate held, which clears 48 hours on paper. Assumed: that the rate holds all the way down, which is their assumption and is optimistic in clay; they filled it again and came back in two days, and it was dry, so the spot potentially clears the Minnesota criterion. Open: how much of the water arriving there is the rear downspout, which discharges onto a splash block 8 feet from the wet strip and runs toward it. What it changed: before engineering anything, they are extending that downspout to discharge 15 feet away on the other side of the path, which costs a part, and will walk the yard again after the next storm. Under these assumptions the strip is a slow-draining compacted area receiving a roof's worth of water, and the compaction is the second problem rather than the first.
Rosalind's strip, Burlington, Vermont. Known: the strip is sandy fill beside a driveway. Hole test: filled, drained in under ten minutes, refilled to 10 inches, and after one hour it stood at 7.5. Rate: 2.5 inches an hour, which reads as fast. Open: whether the driveway sheds water across the strip in a heavy storm, which she has not seen yet because it has not rained hard since she started. What it changed: her expectations in both directions. A fast-draining strip will not drown anything, and it will dry out in a hot week, so the establishment watering in Planting and the first three years matters more here than it would in loam. She noted the driveway question on the survey with a date to check after the next storm, because a strip that is free-draining in normal weather and receives a sheet of drive runoff in a downpour is two conditions, not one.
- University of Minnesota Extension, Building a rain garden: the hole test, the 48-hour criterion, the typical size range and Minnesota's own setbacks.
- US EPA, Soak Up the Rain: Rain Gardens: a federal agency's homeowner guidance on the same idea.
- University of Wisconsin-Madison Extension, Landscape Structures: the slope thresholds for walks, drives and patios, and the lot-line elevation rule.
- US EPA WaterSense, Landscaping Tips: regional tip sheets for water-efficient planting.
9. Practice: dig one hole and measure one slope Practice
Minimum: one hole, two readings, and the downspouts traced. Time: about 30 minutes of actual work, spread across a few hours of waiting for the first fill to drain. Materials: a spade, a bucket or a hose, a ruler or a tape, a watch, and for the slope a straight board, a spirit level and a tape. The site survey's soil sheet has the drainage column.
- Dig the hole where you intend to plant, wide rather than narrow, about 10 inches deep. If you are considering more than one bed, dig a hole in each.
- Fill it and let it drain completely. This is the pre-wetting step and skipping it is the main way this test gives a wrong answer.
- Refill, measure, note the time. Measure from the bottom of the hole, with the ruler held vertically.
- Come back after an hour, measure again, note the time. Put both numbers into the drainage calculator.
- Trace the downspouts while you are waiting, and mark where each one discharges on the base plan.
- Measure one slope with the board and level, on whatever you walk on or plan to build on, and write the percentage down.
The two-day version. The arithmetic version of the test projects a time to empty; the honest version fills the hole and comes back two days later. If the hole is dry, the spot clears Minnesota's criterion with no extrapolation involved. If there is still water in it, it does not, whatever the hourly rate suggested. For any decision that costs money, do the two-day version.
Several holes, one storm. The most informative version of this exercise is to dig three or four holes in different parts of the yard, do them all on the same day, and compare. Differences between holes on the same day are real differences in the ground; differences between holes dug in different months may just be the weather.
Measuring a slope without a board. A line level on a taut string works over longer distances, and a phone's level app on a straight edge works at a pinch. Neither is more accurate than the board; they are more convenient at distance.
10. Your garden Your garden
11. Check your work Check your work
Criteria
- The hole was pre-wetted before the timed fill.
- There is a rate in inches per hour, and a yes or no on the 48-hour question, on the soil sheet.
- The wet areas on the base plan are marked with the date and with how long after rain they were observed.
- Every downspout is traced to where its water actually goes.
- Any surface you walk on or plan to build on has a slope percentage written down.
- Any proposed fix that moves water off the lot is marked as a question for a contractor or the local office, not a weekend job.
- Setback figures on the sheet carry the name of whoever set them.
Worked example
The Okonkwo test (fictional) is a good one and its best feature is what they did with the result. The hole was pre-wetted, two readings were taken an hour apart, and the rate came out at 0.4 inches an hour, which the calculator projected as clearing 48 hours. Rather than acting on the projection they did the two-day version, which confirmed it. Then, instead of reaching for the most interventionist option on the list, they noticed that a downspout was discharging 8 feet upslope of the problem and spent the price of a part on an extension before doing anything else. That is the right order: measure, then eliminate the cheapest cause, then re-observe. What remains open is honest, how much of the water was the roof, and it will be answered by the next storm rather than by argument.
Common mistakes
- Skipping the pre-wetting fill, which gives a reading far faster than the truth.
- Digging a narrow hole, which drains sideways and flatters the result.
- Testing after a dry fortnight and treating the number as typical.
- One hole for a whole yard.
- Blaming the soil for a downspout. Six hundred gallons on one spot is not a soil problem.
- Laying a patio level, or sloping it toward the house.
- Treating a published setback as national. Minnesota's figures govern Minnesota.
- Solving your water problem by sending it next door, which converts an engineering question into a legal one.
What is still unresolved
- Why the ground drains slowly: texture, compaction or a hard layer, which is Soil.
- What the setbacks are where you live: your county's stormwater or environmental health office.
- Whether a regrading or a drain is permitted and how it should be built: a drainage contractor, a civil engineer, and the local building office.
- Which plants tolerate the wet spot you have decided to live with: Choosing plants that fit the place.
- How to size and lay the hard surfaces whose slopes you just measured: Paths, patios and structures.