Surfaces, materials and who does the work
Two tables you can filter: what each hard surface is like to live with and to lay, and which jobs in a small garden build are a reader's, which are a trade's, and where a published threshold draws the line.
Every figure in the second table comes from a publication and says which. The first table carries no prices, for the reason set out in Phasing the work: no published national price figure was found that is honest at the scale of one small garden, so the cost column here describes relative order of cost rather than giving a number. Where a row says "no published source," that is the honest state of it and a figure you find elsewhere is probably a blog's.
Surfaces and materials
Filter by what you care about. The columns that actually decide a small garden are permeability, upkeep and whether you can lay it yourself; appearance is yours and this table has no opinion about it.
| Surface | Permeable | Upkeep | Laying it | Watch for | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Gravel | Yes, where it sits on a permeable base | Raking; topping up every few years; weeding | The most forgiving surface to lay yourself | Migrates without a firm edge restraint; hard going for a wheelchair, a stick or a stroller; travels indoors on shoes | NC State Extension lists gravel among surfacing materials; the failure modes here are this manual's own observation, labeled as such |
| Bark or wood chip | Yes | Topping up; decomposes | Easy | Breaks down and needs replacing; not for a main route in wet weather | Clemson Cooperative Extension gives wood chip lifespans of about 2 years as a mulch |
| Mown grass path | Yes | Mowing, which you are doing anyway | Nothing to lay | Wears to mud on a heavily used line; not usable year round in a wet climate | No published source for width or durability; this is practice |
| Stepping stones in grass or gravel | Yes, between the stones | Re-leveling as they settle; mowing around them | Easy, and the spacing is set by your own stride | A trip hazard if they settle unevenly; no published spacing figure exists | No published source; spacing is practice |
| Concrete pavers or slabs | Only if specified as permeable paving | Weeding the joints; occasional re-leveling | The base course is the part that fails, and it is unforgiving; usually a trade | A quote that does not state the base material and compacted depth is not comparable with one that does | NC State Extension covers pavers among surfacing materials; the base-course point is from Phasing the work |
| Brick | Only with permeable jointing and base | Weeding joints; algae in shade | A trade job for anything structural; a small path is possible with care | Matching the house is NC State Extension's advice, and brick is the case where it matters most | NC State Extension recommends repeating or complementing the house's materials |
| Natural stone | Only with permeable jointing and base | Low, once laid well | Usually a trade; irregular stone is slow and skilled work | Smooth stone in shade grows algae and gets slippery, which is a safety question rather than a taste one | NC State Extension lists stone among surfacing materials |
| Poured concrete | No, unless specified as pervious concrete | Very low | A trade job; the finish and the falls are both skilled | The least reversible surface here; breaking it out later is a real cost | NC State Extension lists concrete among surfacing materials |
| Timber decking | Water passes between boards; the ground beneath is shaded | Cleaning; treating, depending on the timber; boards and fixings eventually | Possible for a low deck; anything raised is structural | Design to standard board lengths of 8, 10 and 12 feet so a deck does not cost extra to be 10 feet 8 inches long | NC State Extension, on designing to standard lumber lengths and on decay-resistant heartwood against pressure-treated lumber |
| Composite decking | As above | Washing | As timber, and the maker's instructions govern spans and fixings | A general figure from any book does not override the maker's installation instructions | NC State Extension covers composites; spans and fixings are product-specific |
| Permeable paving systems | Yes, by design | Keeping the surface clear so it keeps infiltrating | A trade job; the sub-base is the whole point of the system | Treated as a runoff decision rather than a style one | NC State Extension treats permeable paving as a water-conservation and runoff measure |
| Planted ground cover as a surface | Yes | Weeding until it knits; then little | Planting rather than laying | Not a walking surface; it is an alternative to one | NC State Extension treats reducing lawn as a design practice; the figures are in Beds, lawn and use areas |
Lifespans are deliberately absent from this table. The only lifespans this manual found in a publication are Clemson Cooperative Extension's for mulch materials, which are in Planting and the first three years: wood chips decompose within about 2 years, pine needle and bark mulches last about 2 to 4 years, and leaf mold 1 to 2 years. Figures for how long a paving material lasts vary with the base beneath it, the climate and the traffic by more than they vary between materials, and the numbers in circulation are not sourced.
Who does the work
Filter by whether it is yours. The threshold column names the publication where one exists, and says so where none does.
| Job | Whose | The threshold or rule, and who published it |
|---|---|---|
| Any digging at all, including planting a shrub or setting a post | Yours, after the locate | 811 marks the utilities. The Common Ground Alliance names planting trees and shrubs among the projects it covers, says to contact your state's center a few business days ahead, and notes that some utilities are buried just inches down. The notice period is set state by state, so use the state page. |
| A retaining wall | Professional above the threshold | University of Wisconsin-Madison Extension advises seeking professional assistance for a wall more than four feet high, and says a series of low terraced walls is generally preferable to one high wall. |
| Any wall holding ground above a building | Professional at any height | No published height threshold; this manual treats it as professional work at any height because the consequence of failure is structural. |
| Grading that changes where water leaves the lot | Professional, and a permission question | Wisconsin Extension states that ground elevation must match the neighbors' at lot lines. What is permitted is your local building or stormwater office's answer. |
| Assessing, pruning, cabling or felling a mature tree | A certified arborist | No numeric threshold. The credential to ask about is a certified arborist's; damage to roots from excavation can cause a failure years later. |
| Outdoor electrical work on a house circuit | A licensed electrician | Governed by code, including circuit protection and burial depth. A sealed plug-in low-voltage product with its own transformer is a different case and its instructions govern. |
| A drain, dry well or French drain | Usually a contractor | Sized against an infiltration rate and local rules. Minnesota publishes a minimum of 20 feet between a well and drainage features under its Rule 4725.4450, rising to 40 feet for sensitive wells; those are Minnesota's figures and yours come from your own state. |
| Laying out a patio and setting its falls | Design yours; laying usually a trade | Wisconsin Extension: about 64 square feet of hard surface per family member, sloped 1 to 2 percent away from the house. |
| Setting a path's width and slope | Yours | NC State Extension: a front walk at a minimum of 4 1/2 feet so two people can walk abreast. Wisconsin Extension: a walk is ideal at 1 to 4 percent and no more than 6 percent for safety. |
| Building garden steps | Yours for a step or two; otherwise code applies | Wisconsin Extension's long-established outdoor standard: two risers plus one tread equals 26 inches, commonly 5 1/2-inch risers with 15-inch treads or 6-inch risers with 14-inch treads. This is a garden figure, not the indoor stair code, and handrails and riser consistency are governed locally. |
| Surveying the site, reading the sun, testing the drainage | Yours, and nobody does it better than you | No threshold. These are the cheap, high-value parts of the job and they are in Sun, shade and wind, Soil and Water, drainage and slope. |
| Choosing plants and drawing the planting plan | Yours | No threshold. Choosing plants that fit the place and Drawing the planting plan. |
| Planting, mulching and watering | Yours | International Society of Arboriculture: hole 2 to 3 times wider than the root ball and only as deep. Clemson Cooperative Extension: mulch 2 to 3 inches, kept 2 to 3 inches off woody stems. |
| Excavation and removals by machine | Usually hired, for time rather than skill | No threshold. Worth hiring where your own time is the binding constraint; Phasing the work has the arithmetic. |
| Irrigation system design and installation | A trade | Backflow prevention and permits are set locally. This manual covers hand and hose watering through establishment and nothing else. |
| Anything visible from the street where an HOA applies | Yours, after approval | No published threshold. The covenant says what needs approval; the board gives it, in writing, and approval often takes weeks. |
| Anything near a boundary | Yours, once you know where the boundary is | A licensed land surveyor establishes a property line. NC State Extension notes that most property boundaries do not reach the road, so a plant or a wall in the right of way may be torn out. |
These tables are a guide to what to ask and whom, not a specification or a code. Every permit question, every setback and every licensing requirement is set locally and none of them is stated here as a national figure. Where a product is involved, the maker's own installation instructions govern spans, bases, fixings and clearances, and nothing in this manual overrides them. The "whose" column is this manual's judgment about which jobs a householder can reasonably take on; it is not a statement about what you are permitted to do, which depends on where you live.