Phasing the work: what order, what it costs, and what you hire
The design broken into phases that respect the dependencies, costed from your own quotes, measured against the weekends you have, and dated.
- Start here: the essentials
- 1. A finished design is not a finished garden
- 2. The dependency order, and a published alternative
- 3. Costing it from your own numbers
- 4. Your weekends, as a number
- 5. The trade-offs that buy time or money
- 6. Comparing quotes on what they include
- 7. Checking a contractor
- 8. Season, which can make a phase fail
- 9. See it: two schedules
- 10. Practice: write phase one and date it
- 11. Your garden
- 12. Check your work
- 13. Knowledge check and scenario
Start here Essentials
A plan becomes a project when one phase has a date on it. For a single bed that is four steps and half an hour. Everything marked Go deeper is optional on a first pass.
- List what the space needs in dependency order, on the phase sheet (section 2).
- Price the parts from your own quotes and estimates, not from any figure in this manual (section 3).
- Count the half-days you actually have in the months you can work outside (section 4).
- Put a date on phase one and write it in the start column (section 8).
Minimum time: about 30 minutes, once you have quotes. Done when: the phase schedule has at least one phase dated and costed.
1. A finished design is not a finished garden Understand
Most garden design advice ends with the drawing. This chapter exists because the drawing is the halfway point, and because the next decision, what to do first and what to leave, is where most of the money gets wasted or saved.
NC State Extension makes the case for phasing in a way worth quoting back to yourself when you are impatient: completing a landscape over several years is often better as well as cheaper, because it lets you watch plants mature and see how you really use the space before committing to the next piece. Mississippi State Extension's seventh and final step is "establish priorities for implementation," and it notes that a good design provides a plan for phased installation, allowing a large or expensive landscape to be completed in stages as money and time allow. Convention Phasing is the published recommendation, not a concession to poverty.
Two things make a phase plan work, and both are arithmetic rather than judgment: the order, which is fixed by what gets dug up, driven over or walked on by the next piece of work; and the rate, which is set by your money and your time, separately.
And one thing makes a phase plan survive, which is the one-thing question from What the garden has to do. A first phase chosen as "the start of the plan" tends to look like a building site until the rest happens. A first phase chosen as the one thing is complete in itself.
2. The dependency order, and a published alternative
The order below comes from NC State Extension's and Mississippi State Extension's accounts of installation, and from the simple fact that each stage is disturbed by the next.
| Phase | What | Why it comes here |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Utilities marked | Nothing else may happen first, and the notice period is set by your state |
| 2 | Removals: what the survey said goes | Clears the ground and reveals what is underneath |
| 3 | Grading and drainage | Machinery and spoil; everything after this gets walked on by it |
| 4 | Hardscape: paths, patio, steps, walls | Deliveries, cutting, barrows across the site |
| 5 | Soil work: loosen, raise beds, edge | After the compaction from phases 3 and 4, not before |
| 6 | Large plants: trees, then large shrubs | They need access and room to be maneuvered |
| 7 | Small plants: shrubs, perennials, ground layer | Planted around the large material, not before it |
| 8 | Mulch | After planting, and leaving the bare patch if you have one |
| 9 | Lawn: seed or sod what is left | Last, because everything else tracks across it |
There is a published order that disagrees with this, and it is worth seeing rather than hiding. Alabama Cooperative Extension's priority system for spreading installation over time runs: establish a lawn or groundcover first, to prevent soil washing or blowing away; put trees in next, because they take many years to become established; add foundation, corner and entrance plantings; use borders and screens to create spaces; then refinements such as flower beds, ponds, lighting and specimen plants.
The two orders differ because they answer different questions. Convention Alabama's is a priority order, about which pieces of a design deliver most value and most protection first, and its first item is there for erosion control. This manual's is a dependency order, about what physically has to precede what. On a site where bare soil is washing away, Alabama's reasoning for putting cover down early is sound and should win. On a site that is stable, putting lawn in before the hardscape means laying it twice.
The way to use both: take the dependency order as the structure, and let Alabama's priority logic decide what goes in an early phase within what the dependencies allow. If erosion is active, cover the soil now, even temporarily, and accept that some of it will be disturbed later.
3. Costing it from your own numbers
This manual prints no prices. That is a decision rather than an omission, and the reason is worth stating plainly: when this manual was researched, no published national price figure was found that is honest at the scale of one small garden. The numbers that circulate come from lead-generation sites, design blogs and contractors' marketing, and the real cost of a job varies by region, season, access, the state of the ground and who is available that month by more than it varies between projects.
So the arithmetic here runs on your figures:
- Break the work into line items on the phase schedule. One line per thing you would ask somebody to price or buy.
- Get a real number for each. A quote for work you are hiring; a price for a material you are buying; your own estimate where neither exists, marked as an estimate.
- Leave a line blank if you have not priced it. The sheet shows a blank as "unknown" rather than as zero, and a total that sums over a blank is labeled incomplete with the count. That is deliberate: an incomplete total you can see is more use than a confident total that is wrong.
- Put your annual figure in, the amount you can actually spend in a year, from What the garden has to do.
- Divide. The phase calculator gives you the number of years the money takes at that rate.
Two specific costs worth putting on the sheet because they are routinely forgotten: getting rid of things, which is spoil from an excavation, turf you lifted, a shrub you removed and the rubble under it; and access, which is the difference between a truck backing to the bed and twenty barrow trips through a side gate. The second has no price of its own and shows up inside every other line.
4. Your weekends, as a number
Money is the constraint people expect. Time is the one that actually stops most small garden projects, and it is easier to count than people think.
The unit this manual uses is the half-day, about four working hours for one person. Garden work does not come in useful one-hour pieces: there is fetching, there is clearing up, and there is the hour you spend discovering that the ground is full of builders' rubble.
So: half-days a month that you will actually give this, multiplied by the months you can work outside. Four half-days a month over seven workable months is 28 half-days a year. Then estimate the half-days each line item takes, put them on the sheet, and divide.
Be unkind to yourself in the estimate. Convention The useful figure is what you managed last year, not what you intend this year, and for work you have not done before a reasonable habit is to double your first estimate. The phase calculator works money and time separately and tells you which one sets the pace, because a phase can be stopped by either and the longer of the two is what decides the year.
What to do when time is the binding constraint, in rough order of cost:
- Hire the labor-heavy phases. A day of machine work can replace ten of your weekends, and excavation and removals are the usual candidates.
- Cut scope. Fewer plants, smaller terrace, keep the lawn.
- Spread it further. Four years instead of two.
- Get help. Two people are more than twice as fast on anything involving carrying.
5. The trade-offs that buy time or money
NC State Extension's chapter contains the clearest teaching on this found in any source read for this manual, and it is a set of worked trade-offs rather than a rule.
For shade: a planted tree costs least and takes years; an arbor costs more and works as soon as it is built; an umbrella costs little and works today. For a lawn: seed is cheap and slow; sod is dear and fast.
Convention The pattern generalizes, and once you see it you can apply it to almost every line on your sheet.
| What you want | Cheap and slow | Dear and fast | Cheap and immediate, but temporary |
|---|---|---|---|
| Shade over a terrace | Plant a tree | Build an arbor or pergola | An umbrella or a sail |
| Green ground | Seed | Sod | Nothing; or mulch and wait |
| A screen | Small plants at mature spacing | Large specimens, or a fence | A temporary panel or trellis |
| Plants | Small sizes, or divisions from a friend | Large container sizes | Annuals in the gaps |
| A path | Mown grass, or gravel laid yourself | Laid paving | Stepping stones or bark |
The third column is the one that rescues a phase plan, because it lets the one thing happen this year while the permanent version waits for the money. An umbrella over a staked-out terrace tells you whether you will use that terrace, which is information worth having before you pay for the arbor.
6. Comparing quotes on what they include
Two quotes for "a patio" are not comparable, and the difference between them is rarely the thing you are looking at.
What to ask for, so that two quotes become comparable: a written scope you provide, identical to both. Then every quote is answering the same question and the differences are real.
What a scope for garden work should name:
- The work, with dimensions, taken off your plan.
- What happens to spoil and waste, and who pays to remove it.
- For hardscape: excavation depth, the base course material and its compacted depth, edge restraint, the surface material by name and size, jointing, and the falls as a percentage and in which direction.
- For planting: the plant list with botanical names, sizes sold, quantities and spacing, in the form Drawing the planting plan sets out.
- Access: where material comes in and across what.
- Protection: anything to be kept undamaged, especially a tree and its roots.
- What is excluded.
- Who obtains any permit.
Then compare on the quotes sheet, which has a column for what is included and a column for what is excluded, because the exclusions are where the difference usually lives. Convention A quote that is lower because it excludes waste removal, or because it assumes a shallower base, is not a better price; it is a different job.
Ask for the quote in writing, ask what would change the price, and ask what the payment schedule is before any money moves.
Before you pay a deposit, the written scope, the price, the payment schedule and the exclusions should all exist on paper, and you should have read them. What a contract needs to contain, how deposits and progress payments should be structured, and what your rights are if work goes wrong are not questions this manual answers: they are governed by your state's law and by the contract itself. Learn General Contracting's chapter on finding trades and comparing proposals treats this properly, and for anything substantial the answer may be a lawyer rather than a manual.
7. Checking a contractor
NC State Extension makes a blunt point: anyone may call themselves a landscaper. Licensing of landscape contractors varies by state and in many places there is none, so the title on the truck tells you nothing by itself.
What to check, and the quotes sheet has a tick box for two of them:
- Whether your state licenses or registers this trade, which is a question for your state's licensing board, and if it does, whether this firm holds one.
- Insurance, confirmed by a certificate from the insurer naming the dates, not by a claim on a website.
- References you call, for work of the same kind, and ideally a job two or three years old so you can see how it wore. Ask whether the price changed and why.
- Work you look at. A patio two years in tells you about the base course in a way a new one cannot.
- Whether they will work to your scope, which is itself informative. A firm that wants to substitute its own standard detail may be right, and should be able to say why.
Where specialist work is involved, there are credentials that mean something specific. Tree work is the clearest case: a certified arborist holds a credential from a professional body, and for anything involving a mature tree that is the qualification to ask about. Ask the authority For drainage, grading and retaining structures, the question is whether the work needs an engineer's design and whether a permit applies, and your local building office answers both.
8. Season, which can make a phase fail
A phase scheduled for the wrong season is a phase that fails, and it fails in a way that costs the whole phase rather than part of it.
The constraints, roughly:
| Work | Season constraint |
|---|---|
| Grading and excavation | Needs ground that is neither frozen nor saturated; working wet clay does lasting damage |
| Hardscape | Most laying has temperature limits for mortar and jointing; the maker's instructions govern |
| Soil work | Not when frozen, not when sodden |
| Planting trees and shrubs | A regional planting window; ask your extension service, because fall and spring suit different climates differently |
| Seeding a lawn | A narrow regional window tied to soil temperature |
| Mulching | After planting, and generally any time the ground is workable |
Ask the authority The planting windows and the lawn-seeding windows are the two that are genuinely regional, and your county extension office publishes them for your area. This manual gives no national dates because there are none worth giving: fall planting is standard advice in much of the country and a mistake in parts of the upper midwest and mountain west where young roots cannot establish before the ground freezes.
The scheduling consequence is that your phases are not free to slide. A planting phase that slips past its window waits a full season, which may mean a year. When you write the start dates on the phase sheet, work backward from the planting windows rather than forward from today.
One more piece of ordering advice, from NC State Extension's point about watching plants mature: if a later phase depends on how big something has got, give it a year rather than a date. "After the screen has had two seasons" is a legitimate entry in the start column.
9. See it: two schedules See it
Rosalind's strip, Burlington, Vermont. Known: $150 and two weekends, which is four half-days; one bed, 12 by 4 feet; no hardscape; nine plants from Drawing the planting plan; sandy fill; a marked gas line down the middle. Her line items, priced from her own local figures: plants, mulch for about 37 square feet at 3 inches, a bag of compost, and the 811 call at no cost. Her sheet: the whole project is one phase, which is the correct answer at this scale. Phase one: call 811, hand-clear the strip, plant, mulch, water. Dependency order is preserved and compressed into one weekend plus a second for the watering and tidying. Assumed: that two weekends is enough, which she estimated and then doubled on the advice in section 4, giving four half-days against an estimate of two. Open: the planting window, which she checked with the county extension office rather than guessing, because Vermont's spring is short and a May planting and a September planting are different propositions. What it changed: nothing about the design and everything about the date. She had intended to do it "in the spring." The schedule has a specific weekend on it, chosen to sit inside the window the extension office gave, and that is the difference between a plan and a project.
The Okonkwo yard, Columbus, Ohio. Known: $4,000 over three years, so about $1,300 a year; most Saturdays from April to October, which they counted honestly as four half-days a month over seven months, 28 a year; a terrace, a screen bed, the wet west side, a hardpan under the lawn, and planting. The calculator, with their figures: total cost of everything still to do, $3,900 from their own quotes and prices; total of their own labor, 34 half-days. On money that is 3.0 years. On time it is 1.2 years. So money sets the pace, by 1.8 years, and the plan is three phases rather than two. Assumed: that the patio laying is quoted out, which it is, and that no permit is needed, which they asked the building office rather than assumed. Open: whether the wet west side needs a contractor, which Water, drainage and slope left open pending a storm after the downspout extension. Their phases: year one, 811, the downspout extension, removals, and the terrace, because the terrace is their one thing and the downspout may solve the drainage for the price of a part. Year two, the soil work and the screen bed's large plants, which need to go in early so they have two seasons before they are judged. Year three, the smaller planting, the mulch and whatever the lawn needs. The entry worth copying: the screen bed's start column says "spring, year two, inside the planting window," not a date, because the window is the constraint and the exact Saturday is not.
- NC State Extension Gardener Handbook, chapter 19: the case for completing a landscape over several years, the cheap-and-slow against dear-and-fast trade-offs, and the point that anyone may call themselves a landscaper.
- Mississippi State University Extension, Home Landscape Design: establishing priorities for implementation as the final step, and phased installation as something a good design provides for.
- Alabama Cooperative Extension System, Residential Landscape Design: the published priority order that puts lawn or groundcover first for erosion control.
10. Practice: write phase one and date it Practice
Minimum: the dependency list on the sheet, at least one line priced, the half-days counted, and a date in the start column of phase one. Time: about 30 minutes, once you have quotes; getting the quotes takes longer and is not your work. Materials: the phase schedule, your plan, and whatever prices and quotes you hold.
- Open the phase sheet, which is already in dependency order, and delete the rows that do not apply to your project.
- Add your own line items under the right phase, one per thing you would price or buy.
- Put a real number against every line you can, and leave the rest blank rather than guessing. Blanks read as unknown.
- Estimate half-days per line, then double anything you have not done before.
- Put your annual figure and your half-days a month into the phase calculator and read which constraint sets the pace.
- Check the season for anything that plants or seeds, by asking your county extension office for the window.
- Write a date in the start column of phase one. If a phase depends on a window rather than a date, write the window.
Phasing when you may move within five years
The calculation changes, and the honest version is to split the list into what you take with you, what pays back in one season, and what is a gift to the next owner. Containers, tools, furniture and some plants travel. A terrace does not. If you may move, front-load the things you will use and enjoy and defer the permanent ones, which is close to the opposite of the advice for someone staying twenty years. Nothing in the dependency order changes; what changes is which phases are worth reaching.
The cheapest first phase that still looks deliberate
A first phase that leaves the garden looking unfinished is demoralizing and tends to stall the rest. The cheapest combinations that read as finished, in roughly ascending order: a defined bed edge with mulch and three repeated plants; a mown path through longer grass; a staked and umbrella-shaded sitting area on gravel; one tree with a mulch circle and a bench. Each of those is a complete thing rather than a fragment of a plan, which is the quality the one-thing question is looking for.
Doing the design yourself and hiring the build
This is a common and sensible split, and it is the position Mississippi State Extension describes when it says you can hire a professional for a particular step without hiring one for the whole design. The things worth hiring, for most small gardens: excavation and removals, anything structural, anything electrical, tree work, and hardscape laying where a base course is involved. The things worth keeping: the survey, the brief, the plant choices and the plan, because they are where the knowledge of your own site lives and because they are the cheap part.
11. Your garden Your garden
12. Check your work Check your work
Criteria
- The phases are in dependency order, and anything that departs from it has a reason written down.
- Every priced line has a real number from a quote, a price or a marked estimate; unpriced lines are blank, not zero.
- Waste removal and access appear somewhere on the sheet.
- Half-days are counted for the months you can actually work outside.
- You know which constraint sets the pace, money or time.
- Two quotes for the same work answer the same written scope.
- Exclusions are recorded alongside inclusions for every quote.
- Anything that plants or seeds is checked against a regional window, not a guess.
- Phase one has a date, or a named window, in the start column.
Worked example
The Okonkwo schedule (fictional) is the better of the two because the arithmetic told them something they did not expect. They had assumed time was their constraint, since they both work and the garden gets Saturdays. The numbers say otherwise: 34 half-days of their own labor against 28 available in a year is 1.2 years, while $3,900 at $1,300 a year is 3.0. Money sets the pace by nearly two years, which means hiring more of the work would not help them and cutting scope or spreading it further would. That is a conclusion you cannot reach by feeling. The second thing worth copying is the start column on the screen bed: "spring, year two, inside the planting window" rather than a date, because the window is the real constraint and writing a specific Saturday two years out would be false precision. The weakness, which they have recorded honestly, is that the wet west side is still unresolved and could become a contractor line that changes the money arithmetic.
Common mistakes
- Planting before grading or hardscape, and then walking machinery over the planting.
- Laying a lawn before the hard work is done, and laying it twice.
- Putting zero in a cost column when the real state is "not priced yet."
- Forgetting waste removal, which is a real line on nearly every project.
- Forgetting access, which silently multiplies every other line.
- Estimating your own labor optimistically, especially for work you have not done.
- Comparing two quotes that answer different questions.
- Paying a deposit before the scope is written down.
- Scheduling planting outside the regional window, which loses a season rather than a weekend.
- A first phase that is a fragment, so the garden looks like a building site until a later phase that may not come.
What is still unresolved
- What anything costs where you live: your own quotes, and nothing in this manual.
- What a contract should contain and what your rights are: your state's law, a contract, and possibly a lawyer. Learn General Contracting's chapter on finding trades and comparing proposals is the better starting point.
- Whether a permit is needed, and who gets it: your local building or planning office.
- Your regional planting and seeding windows: your county extension office.
- Whether a drainage problem needs an engineer: a contractor and the building office, from Water, drainage and slope.
- How to plant and water what the phases deliver: Planting and the first three years.