What the garden has to do: writing a brief before you draw
Who uses the space and for what, what stays, what the money and the weekends really are, and the one thing the garden has to deliver first.
- Start here: the essentials
- 1. What a brief is, and what it prevents
- 2. The activity list, with numbers attached
- 3. Where each activity belongs
- 4. What stays, and who decides
- 5. What the money and the weekends really are
- 6. Ruling work out early
- 7. The one-thing question
- 8. See it: four briefs
- 9. Practice: write the brief
- 10. Your garden
- 11. Check your work
- 12. Knowledge check and scenario
Start here Essentials
A brief is a page of writing, done before any measuring and long before any buying. For one bed it takes twenty minutes. Everything marked Go deeper is optional on a first pass.
- Write what the space is for, in one sentence. Not a style, a job: what it has to let somebody do (section 1).
- Count the people and the hours. How many people use it, how often, and how many hours a week you can give it (section 2, section 5).
- List what stays. The tree, the fence, the patio, the dog run, anything you are not allowed to touch (section 4).
- Name the one thing it must deliver. If only one phase ever happens, which one (section 7).
Minimum time: about 20 minutes with a pen. Done when: a brief of under ten lines is saved to your garden file, and it names a number of people and one thing that has to happen first.
1. What a brief is, and what it prevents Understand
A brief is the short written statement of what the garden has to do. It is not a design, a plant list or a wish board. It is the document you hold up six months later when somebody at a nursery, or somebody inside your own head, says "wouldn't it be lovely to have a pond here," and you read your own sentence back and remember that the space has to hold a bin store, a line of washing and a dog.
Every published design process begins with some version of this step, and it is worth noticing how consistently. NC State Extension's six-step sequence puts determining activities and uses third, after the base plan and the site survey but before any drawing of the design itself. Mississippi State Extension's seven steps put "assess family needs and desires" third, in the same position. Oklahoma State Extension's three-part frame runs site evaluation, then landscaping goals, then the bubble diagram. Convention These are all extension publications written for homeowners, not professional training, and they agree: the statement of needs comes before the drawing.
The reason is unglamorous. A design without a brief drifts toward whatever the person doing it has recently seen. It acquires features rather than uses. It ends as a collection of things that were each a good idea on the day, sited where there happened to be room, and it is the commonest reason a garden feels like nowhere in particular to sit. A brief does not stop you changing your mind. It makes changing your mind a decision you notice.
The second thing a brief does is settle arguments before they become expensive. Two people in a household who have not said out loud what the space is for tend to discover the disagreement when the concrete is poured. Writing the sentence down surfaces it in week one, when the cost of being wrong is a sheet of paper.
A brief is a statement of intent, not a guarantee. It cannot tell you whether the thing you want will fit, drain, grow or get planning permission, and it routinely gets cut down by the survey: the place you imagined the seating is the place the water stands, the tree you planned for is under a power line, the screen you wanted is on your neighbor's land. Write the brief so that the survey can argue with it. Do not commit money to a brief that has not met a site yet.
2. The activity list, with numbers attached
The useful form of a brief is a list of activities, each with a number of people beside it. "Somewhere to sit" is not a brief. "Four adults eating dinner, twice a month in summer" is a brief, because it can be sized, and sizing is the whole point. The number of people is what turns a wish into a dimension.
Both NC State Extension and Oklahoma State Extension put this plainly: the uses come from who lives here and what they do, and the areas get sized from that. A table for four needs the table, the chairs pulled out, and room to walk behind somebody who is sitting. Convention NC State gives 2 to 3 feet of walking room around outdoor chairs, and that figure alone is often what decides whether a small terrace is pleasant or a place where someone has to stand up every time the salad is passed.
Write the list in the second person plural of your actual household, not of a household in a catalog. The following prompts are more useful than a blank page.
| Ask | Why it is on the list | What to write down |
|---|---|---|
| Who lives here, and who visits? | Numbers size areas; ages decide surfaces and sight lines | Adults, children with ages, dogs, regular visitors |
| What already happens out there? | Existing habits are the most reliable predictor of future ones | Where people actually stand, sit, walk and put things |
| What do you want to happen that does not? | This is the part a design can change | One line per activity, with how many people and how often |
| What has to be stored or hidden? | Bins, bikes, firewood, a compost heap and a hose all need a home | Each item, its size, and how often it is fetched |
| What are you looking at from inside? | Most people see the garden through a window more than they stand in it | Which windows, and what is in the view |
| Who maintains it, and for how long? | Upkeep is a use, and the commonest one to leave off | Hours a week, and who is doing them in five years |
Two of those are routinely forgotten. Storage is forgotten because it is ugly, and then the bins end up in the only sunny corner. Upkeep is forgotten because it is in the future, and then a planting designed on an optimistic spring afternoon becomes a reproach by its third August. Put both on the list with numbers: three bins fetched weekly; four hours a week in season, dropping to one in winter.
Designing for a household that will change. A brief written for children aged 6 and 9 is a brief with an expiry date. NC State Extension's chapter makes the point that household needs change, and the practical version is to ask what each area becomes next. A flat, open play lawn becomes a lawn, or a terrace, or a bed, without demolition. A fixed play structure on a concrete pad becomes a demolition job. The cheapest way to design for change is to put the permanent money into the things that serve any use (level ground, a path, a boundary, a tree) and the temporary money into the things that serve this year's use.
The same logic runs the other way for a household that is about to acquire a use rather than lose one. If a dog is likely within two years, the gate latches, the fence gaps and the lawn are already decisions, and they are cheaper now than later.
3. Where each activity belongs
Once the list exists, each item needs a rough home. NC State Extension describes a residential lot as having three broad areas: a public area at the front, seen from the street; a private area, usually behind the house, for the household's own use; and a service area for the work of the house, the bins, the tools, the compost, the drying. Convention It is a way of asking a question rather than a rule about where things go: for each activity, is this something the street sees, something the household uses, or something that has to happen and should not be the first thing you look at?
The model fails cleanly, which is a virtue. On a narrow urban lot there is often no service area, and the bins live in the front because that is where the street is. On a corner lot, two sides are public. On a property where the kitchen door faces the drive, the service area and the entrance are the same ground. When the model does not fit, it has still done its work by making you notice that the bins have nowhere to go.
At this stage the assignment is a word, not a place. "Bins: service, near the gate." "Eating: private, near the kitchen door." The actual geometry waits for Beds, lawn and use areas, which does it with bubble diagrams on the measured plan. What you are doing now is noticing conflicts: two activities that both want the sunny corner, or a service need that has been quietly assigned to the one place you also wanted to sit.
4. What stays, and who decides
The brief has a second half, which is everything already on the site that the design has to accept. Some of it stays because you want it. Some stays because moving it is somebody else's job, or because you are not allowed to touch it.
List each item and mark it keep, move, remove or ask. Put the list on the site survey's "What is already there" sheet, with the reason in the why column, because the reason is what stops the argument restarting every weekend. Ask the authority The "ask" category is larger than most people expect, and it is worth knowing which questions are not yours to answer before you spend a Saturday on an assumption.
| Thing | Who decides | What to ask |
|---|---|---|
| A mature tree | A certified arborist, and possibly a local tree ordinance | Is it sound? What is its mature spread? Is it protected? |
| A fence or wall on the boundary | The deed, and your neighbor | Whose is it? Where is the line actually drawn? |
| Anything in a rented garden | The landlord, in writing | Beds? Containers? Digging? Structures? Who inherits it? |
| Anything visible from the street in an HOA | The covenant and the board | What needs approval, and how long does approval take? |
| A septic field or tank | Whoever services it | Where are the lines? What may be planted or parked over them? |
| A utility easement | The deed or plat, and the utility | Who may dig here, and what may they remove without asking? |
The last row is the one that surprises people most. An easement is a right somebody else holds over part of your land, and it can mean that a planting you paid for is removed without notice when the line beneath it is worked on. Measuring and drawing your site covers how to find out, and the questions sheet in the survey is where the answers go.
5. What the money and the weekends really are
Two numbers belong on the brief, and both are usually avoided.
The first is money, per year. Not the total you imagine spending, which is a daydream, but the amount you can actually put into this in a year without resentment. Per year is the useful unit because almost every small garden gets built over several years, and because the question "can I afford this garden" has no answer while the question "what fits in this year" has a very clear one.
This manual prints no prices. That is a deliberate decision and worth saying out loud: when this manual was researched, no published national price list was found that is honest at the scale of one small garden. The figures that circulate come from design blogs, lead-generation sites and contractors' marketing, and they vary by region, season, access and the state of the ground by more than they vary between projects. Ask the authority So the arithmetic here runs on your own quotes and your own estimates, which you enter on the phase schedule, and the phase calculator tells you how many years they take at your rate. Two figures in this whole manual are published dollar-adjacent claims, both about property value, both attributed and both ranged, and they appear in the fictional cases below only as something to be skeptical about.
The second number is hours, per week, in season. Be unkind to yourself here. The honest figure is the one you managed last year, not the one you intend. A half-day, four working hours, is the planning unit used throughout this manual, because garden work does not come in useful one-hour pieces: there is fetching, there is clearing up, and there is the hour when you discover the ground is full of builders' rubble.
Those two numbers interact in a way that catches people out. Money and time are separate constraints, and a plan can be stopped by either. A household with a reasonable budget and no weekends is in a different situation from a household with every Saturday and no money, and the two should build the same design in a different order. Phasing the work is where that gets worked out; what the brief has to do is write both numbers down so that it can be.
What property value has to do with it, which is less than you will be told. Two extension publications put a figure on landscaping and property value, and both are worth reading carefully rather than quoting. Mississippi State Extension's Home Landscape Design says a well-designed landscape "can increase the value of your home and property by as much as 15 percent." Alabama Cooperative Extension's Residential Landscape Design says the value of a home "can be increased by as much as 6 to 15 percent as a result of a good landscape," and adds, in the same paragraph, that the landscape is not the most valuable feature of the property; the house is.
Convention Notice the shape of both claims. Each is a ceiling ("as much as"), neither is a measured resale return on a particular project, and neither is a reason to spend money you do not have. A garden built because you want to be in it is a defensible purchase. A garden built as an investment on the strength of a range quoted by a third party is not a calculation this manual can help you make, and nothing in these pages should be read as advice about what your property is worth.
6. Ruling work out early
Some jobs are not yours. Naming them now, in the brief, is cheaper than discovering it in the middle of a phase, and it changes what the rest of the brief may contain.
- Retaining walls. University of Wisconsin-Madison Extension advises seeking professional assistance for a retaining wall more than four feet high, and notes that a series of low terraced walls is generally preferable to one high wall. Ask the authority Anything holding ground above a building, at any height, is in the same category.
- Grading that changes where water leaves the lot. The same publication states that ground elevation must match the neighbors' at lot lines. Water you redirect becomes somebody else's water, and that is a liability as well as an engineering question.
- Tree work. Assessing whether a tree is sound, pruning a mature one, cabling or felling: a certified arborist's job, and not a matter of nerve.
- Electrical work. Outdoor circuits, lighting on a house supply, pond pumps.
- Anything needing a permit. Wisconsin Extension's advice is to check local ordinances or obtain a building permit before construction. What needs one is set locally, so it is a question, not a figure.
Write the ruled-out list on the brief as a short paragraph: "Not us: the wall at the back, any change to the drainage, the maple." Then the rest of the brief can be ambitious without being dishonest. Paths, patios and structures goes through each of these in detail, and the who-does-the-work table lists them against the question each one raises.
7. The one-thing question
End the brief with a single question: if only one phase of this ever happens, which one is it?
This is the most useful line on the page, and it is the one most people resist writing, because it requires admitting that the whole thing might not happen. It is also the question that makes the first phase good. A first phase chosen as "the start of the plan" tends to be foundations: something that only makes sense once the rest exists, and that looks like a building site for two years if the rest does not. A first phase chosen as the one thing tends to be complete in itself: the terrace you actually sit on, the screen that removes the view of the garage wall, the bed by the door that you see every day.
NC State Extension makes a related point about phasing that is worth carrying into this question: completing a landscape over several years is often better as well as cheaper, because it lets you watch plants mature and see how you really use the space before committing to the next piece. The one-thing question turns that from a consolation into a method.
8. See it: four briefs See it
Four fictional people appear throughout this manual with fixed facts. Here are their briefs, written as they would be at this stage, before anything has been measured.
Rosalind Pike, Burlington, Vermont. Known: a strip 12 feet by 4 feet between her driveway and a chain-link fence; sandy fill left by a sewer repair; $150 and two weekends; she wants pollinators and does not want the neighbors to think she has stopped mowing. Her brief: "This strip is the first thing anyone sees arriving, and it has to look deliberate from the sidewalk and feed bees. One person maintains it, about an hour a week in season. Nothing stays; there is nothing there. Not us: nothing, there is no hard work in this. The one thing: something in flower that looks cared for by the end of the first summer." Assumed: that the fill drains fast, which she has not tested; the test in Water, drainage and slope settles it. Open: whether the strip is actually hers or lies in the public right of way, which the deed and the city settle, not she.
The Okonkwo household, Columbus, Ohio. Known: a 1958 ranch; back yard 48 by 32 feet, fenced; a healthy 40-year-old silver maple in the northwest corner that is staying; clay compacted along one side by a 2024 sewer dig where water stands for two days after rain; two children aged 6 and 9 and a terrier; $4,000 over three years and most Saturdays from April to October. Their brief: "Six people at a table twice a month in summer; two children and a dog using open ground most days; the neighbor's garage wall hidden from the kitchen window; something for bees. Stays: the maple, the fence, the gate. Not us: the wet strip if it turns out to need regrading, and anything to the maple. The one thing: dry, usable ground where the water stands, because that is the half of the yard the children do not use." Assumed: that the wet strip is compaction rather than a drainage path from the roof, whose assumption that is matters; the downspout check in Water, drainage and slope decides it. Open: whether the maple's mature spread leaves room for the table, which the measured plan answers.
Dee Marchetti, Providence, Rhode Island. Known: she rents the ground floor of a triple-decker; a back yard 14 by 20 feet, in the building's shadow until about 1 p.m. then bright until evening; the landlord allows beds and containers, no structures and no digging deeper than a spade; $300, no machinery, and she may move in two years. Her brief: "One person, sitting outside with coffee most mornings and with two friends occasionally. Shade-tolerant planting I can see from the kitchen. Nothing permanent. Stays: everything, because none of it is mine. Not us: anything structural, by the landlord's rule and by the lease. The one thing: somewhere to sit that is not looking at the trash cans." Assumed: that the morning shade means a shade planting, which four readings in Sun, shade and wind may well overturn, since bright afternoon sun can total more hours than she expects. Open: what the landlord's permission covers in writing, which only the landlord settles.
Harlan Vrba, Austin, Texas. Known: a front yard 30 by 22 feet, full afternoon sun, St. Augustine lawn he wants gone; watering allowed two days a week; an HOA that requires a "maintained" front appearance and approves plans; $9,000 and no intention of doing the work himself. His brief: "Two adults, who use the front yard only to walk from the car to the door. Replace the lawn with planting that survives two watering days a week and reads as maintained to the HOA. Stays: the drive and the walk. Not us: all of it; this is being hired out. The one thing: the lawn gone and replaced with something the board has approved in advance." Assumed: that he has been quoted fairly, which he cannot tell; Phasing the work gives him the comparison. Open: what the HOA will actually approve, which the board settles and nobody else.
Notice what the four briefs have in common. Each names a number of people. Each names what stays. Each names what is not theirs. Each ends with one thing. None of them mentions a plant.
- NC State Extension Gardener Handbook, chapter 19: Landscape Design: the six-step process this manual follows, with the public, private and service areas and the figures for walking room and front walks.
- Mississippi State University Extension, Home Landscape Design (P2698): seven steps ending in establishing priorities for implementation, and the suggestion to watch a site for a year before changing it.
- Oklahoma State University Extension, Planning the Landscape (HLA-6440): site evaluation, goals and the bubble diagram, with its own site-inventory checklist.
9. Practice: write the brief Practice
Minimum: the activity list with numbers, the list of what stays, and the one-thing sentence, on one side of paper. Time: about 20 minutes, or an hour if more than one person is involved and they disagree. Materials: a pen, one sheet of paper, and the site survey's "What is already there" sheet in a browser tab.
- Write the activity list. One line per activity, each with a number of people and a frequency. Include storage and upkeep. Do not edit as you go; get everything down first.
- Mark each activity public, private or service, and put a star against any two that want the same ground. Those are the conflicts the layout has to resolve.
- List what stays, with keep, move, remove or ask against each, and the reason. Put it on the survey's features sheet so it survives the weekend.
- Write the two numbers: what you can spend in a year, and how many hours a week you really have in season.
- Write the ruled-out paragraph and the one thing. Then read the whole page back and cut anything that is a style rather than a use.
If more than one person is involved, have each write their own activity list separately before comparing. Lists written together converge on whoever speaks first. Compared afterward, the gaps are informative: one person's list will have upkeep on it and the other's will not, or one will have assumed the lawn is for children and the other that it is for the dog.
If you have just moved in, there is a case for writing the brief and then doing almost nothing for a year. Mississippi State Extension suggests recording observations of the site for a year before changing it, on the grounds that moving fast can destroy an asset before you know it is one. That is the single cheapest piece of advice in this manual and the hardest to follow. A compromise that keeps most of the value: write the brief now, do one small reversible thing this season, and let the survey accumulate through a full cycle of weather before the first real phase.
10. Your garden Your garden
11. Check your work Check your work
Criteria
- Every activity on the list has a number of people and a frequency beside it, not just a name.
- Storage and upkeep are both on the list.
- What stays is written down with a reason, not held in somebody's head.
- There are two numbers on the page: money per year, and hours per week in season.
- The ruled-out paragraph names at least the categories that apply to this site.
- There is exactly one "one thing", and it is something that would be worth having on its own.
- Nothing on the brief is a plant, a material or a style.
Worked example
The Okonkwo household's brief (fictional) meets the criteria. Six people at a table twice a month is a number and a frequency; two children and a dog on open ground most days is another. Storage is implied rather than stated, which is the brief's weakest line and would be worth fixing: where do the bikes go? What stays is specific, and the reason for keeping the maple is that it is healthy and 40 years old, which is a reason that could in principle change if an arborist disagreed. The two numbers are there, $4,000 over three years and most Saturdays from April to October, which converts to roughly $1,300 a year and perhaps four half-days a month in season. The ruled-out paragraph names the regrading and the tree. And the one thing, dry usable ground where the water stands, is the right shape: complete in itself, worth having even if nothing else follows, and it also happens to unlock everything else, because nothing can be built on ground that stands in water. The brief does not mention a single plant, and at this stage that is correct.
Common mistakes
- Writing a style instead of a use. "Cottage garden" is not a brief. It is an answer to a question nobody has asked yet, and it commits you to a look before you know what the space has to do.
- Leaving the numbers off. "Somewhere to sit" gives nothing to size. "Four people eating" does.
- Omitting upkeep. The commonest single omission, and the one that turns a design into a reproach.
- Writing a total rather than a per-year figure. A total answers no question you are about to face.
- Assuming what stays is up to you. A tree may be protected, a fence may be your neighbor's, a rented garden is somebody else's property.
- Refusing the one-thing question. "All of it matters" is a way of not deciding, and it reliably produces a first phase that looks like a building site.
What is still unresolved
- Whether any of this fits: that is the measured plan in Measuring and drawing your site, and it is normal for the survey to kill one item on the brief.
- Where each activity goes: Beds, lawn and use areas, once there is a drawing to put bubbles on.
- What the money buys: nobody can say until you have quotes, which is Phasing the work.
- Whether what stays can stay: an arborist for a tree, the deed for a boundary, the landlord or the board for permission. None of those is a question this manual answers.