Beds, lawn and use areas: dividing a small space so it works
Bubble diagrams, areas sized for the people who use them, bed depths chosen on purpose, a decision about how much lawn, and sight lines placed.
- Start here: the essentials
- 1. The bubble diagram, the cheapest drawing there is
- 2. Sizing an area to the people in it
- 3. Bed depth, and what a shallow bed can hold
- 4. Lines, curves and edges
- 5. How much lawn, and where
- 6. Views: what to frame and what to hide
- 7. Service: bins, storage and getting things in
- 8. Proportion in a small space
- 9. See it: three layouts
- 10. Practice: three bubble diagrams and a stake-out
- 11. Your garden
- 12. Check your work
- 13. Knowledge check and scenario
Start here Essentials
This is the cheapest stage of the whole process: paper, a pencil and some string. The aim is a layout you have tested on the ground before anything is bought. Everything marked Go deeper is optional on a first pass.
- Draw three rough versions, not one. Bubbles on tracing paper over the base plan, labeled by use (section 1).
- Size each area for the number of people and furniture it holds, with walking room around chairs (section 2).
- Stake the best version on the ground with canes, string or a hose, and leave it a day (section 10).
- Stand at the window you look out of most and look at what you have staked (section 6).
Minimum time: about 40 minutes drawing, 20 minutes staking, and a day of looking. Done when: one bubble diagram is chosen and its edges are staked on the ground.
1. The bubble diagram, the cheapest drawing there is Understand
A bubble diagram is a loose drawing over your base plan in which each use area is a blob with a label. "Sitting." "Play." "Bins." "Screen." No shapes, no materials, no plants. Oklahoma State Extension describes it as a way to define use areas and visualize how they fit together, with the bubbles roughly corresponding to the shape and size of the planned areas and continuing to be refined through the design.
The step exists because it is almost free and because it is the one place where you can be wrong at no cost. The instruction both Oklahoma State and NC State give, and the one most people skip, is to make several and then pick. Oklahoma State's wording is direct: create several potential bubble drawings and select the best one.
Three is a good number. Not three variations of the same idea with the terrace moved a foot, but three genuinely different propositions:
- One that puts the main use where it obviously goes, by the door.
- One that puts it as far from the house as the space allows.
- One that gives up something on the brief, the lawn, say, or the storage, and uses the room that frees.
The third is the useful one, because it tests whether the brief is really a brief or just a list. Drawing it does not commit you to it. Refusing to draw it usually means you have already decided.
What goes on each diagram: the survey's findings, not just the uses. The wet corner, the full-shade band under the tree, the marked utility line, the hot west wall. Convention A bubble diagram drawn without the survey on it is a wish list with curved edges, and the commonest result is a sitting area in the only part of the yard that stands in water.
2. Sizing an area to the people in it
This is the step that turns the brief's numbers into dimensions, and it is usually a shock on a small lot.
NC State Extension's method for a sitting area is practical and worth following exactly: an outdoor dining area should comfortably accommodate the maximum number of guests who will use the space; measure the outdoor furniture planned for the space and allow 2 to 3 feet of walking room around chairs; using the plan's scale, cut out paper furniture pieces to size and move them around on the plan to find a location. Then stake off the space to see whether it is the right size, whether the location takes advantage of good viewpoints, and whether the site suits it.
Work an example. A table for six is commonly around 6 feet by 3. Chairs pulled out add roughly 2 feet on each side that has one, so about 10 feet by 7 for the furniture footprint. Adding 2 to 3 feet of walking room on the sides where people pass brings it to something like 14 by 11, which is 154 square feet. In a back yard 48 by 32 that is a tenth of the total. In a yard 14 by 20 it is more than half, and the conclusion to draw is not that the figures are wrong but that a table for six does not belong in that yard.
Wisconsin Extension offers a different route to the same kind of number, useful as a cross-check: about 64 square feet of hard-surfaced patio per family member. For a household of four that is 256 square feet, which is a terrace about 16 feet square. Convention Two published figures, two methods, and they often disagree: the furniture method sizes for an occasion, the per-person figure sizes for a household. Use the furniture method when you know what furniture you will have, and the per-person figure as a sanity check when you do not. Paths, patios and structures takes this further for hard surfaces specifically.
Other areas get sized the same way, by what goes in them:
| Area | Sized by | What people forget |
|---|---|---|
| Dining or sitting | The furniture plus 2 to 3 feet of walking room around chairs (NC State) | That chairs pull out, and that somebody has to get past |
| Play | What the children actually do, and the swing of any equipment | The fall zone around equipment, and that it changes every three years |
| Dog | A run or a loop, and the line the dog already walks | That dogs make their own paths and will keep using them |
| Bins and storage | The bins themselves plus the route to the street | The width a wheeled bin needs, and the gate it goes through |
| Growing food | Reach: a bed wider than about 4 feet needs stepping into | That you have to get a wheelbarrow to it |
| Beds and borders | Mature plant sizes, which is section 3 | Nearly everything |
Cut the paper pieces. It takes ten minutes and it is the most effective thing in this chapter, because a scale cut-out of a table resists the optimism a pencil sketch invites.
3. Bed depth, and what a shallow bed can hold
Bed depth is the front-to-back dimension, and it is a decision rather than whatever is left over after the lawn.
UF/IFAS Extension gives a published range: plant bed depth typically runs from about 5 feet for a shallow bed to 30 feet for a deep one. That is a wide range and the width of it is the point: a 5-foot bed is a real bed, and a 30-foot bed is a different kind of planting entirely.
What a bed can hold follows from the arithmetic the whole manual rests on, which is that a plant is a circle at its mature spread. In a bed 4 feet deep:
| Mature spread | How many rows fit in a 4-foot bed | What that means |
|---|---|---|
| 1 foot | Four rows, or three with a working gap | A ground-layer or small-perennial bed |
| 2 feet | Two rows | A perennial border; one row of two sizes |
| 3 feet | One row, with a foot spare | A single line of shrubs, which reads as a hedge rather than a border |
| 5 feet | One plant, overhanging front and back | The bed is too shallow for the plant, not the other way round |
This is the arithmetic that makes people widen their beds, and it is why the bed line is drawn before the plants are chosen in Drawing the planting plan. A bed 3 feet deep planted with shrubs that reach 5 feet across will be, in six years, a row of shrubs with their fronts cut off by the mower and their backs against the fence. The common response is to prune, forever. The cheaper response is a deeper bed or smaller plants, decided now.
Against a wall there is a second constraint. NC State Extension's rule is that plants near buildings are set half their mature width plus at least a foot from the structure, so a shrub that will be 5 feet across sits 3 1/2 feet out from the wall. Convention A foundation bed 3 feet deep therefore has no room for that shrub, whatever else you do to it, and this is the arithmetic behind every overgrown foundation planting you have ever seen pressed against a window.
Alabama Extension adds a point about what a bed is: landscape plants should be arranged in defined, mulched beds, rather than dotted individually into lawn. Convention A bed is a shape with an edge. Plants scattered in grass are harder to mow around, harder to water and read as clutter; the same plants inside one defined shape read as a planting.
4. Lines, curves and edges
The shape of a bed line is mostly taste, and there is one published piece of advice worth having. UF/IFAS Extension's guidance for bed lines is to use very wide, deep curves, half circles or three-quarter circles, at outside and inside corners. Convention The reasoning is practical as much as visual: a generous curve can be mown around and holds its shape as plants grow, while a tight wiggle disappears within two seasons and is awkward to maintain in the meantime.
The test for any bed line is whether you can walk it with a mower or a wheelbarrow without reversing. If you cannot, it will be simplified by whoever maintains it, and that will be you.
Lay the line out with a hose or a rope before you cut it. A hose on the ground on a mild day will show you in ten minutes what a drawing cannot: whether the curve reads from the window, whether it leaves a usable piece of lawn, and whether the bed you have drawn is the shape you want or just the shape left over.
5. How much lawn, and where
Lawn is the default rather than a decision in most American yards, which is exactly why it is worth deciding on purpose.
Start with the question the brief should already have answered: what is the lawn for? There are real answers. Children playing. A dog. A surface you can walk on barefoot and put a chair on anywhere. A quiet green plane that makes the planting around it read as planting. Those are uses, and a lawn that serves one of them is doing a job no other surface does as cheaply.
There are also non-answers: because it was there; because the alternative is work; because the neighbors have one. Those are worth naming, because they are the cases where reducing lawn costs you nothing you were using.
NC State Extension's position in its water-conservation section is that reducing the size of the lawn is a design practice for conserving water, and notes that as much as half of all water used outdoors by the average homeowner goes to lawn irrigation. The same chapter observes that a front yard without a lawn can work. Convention Neither of those is an instruction to remove your lawn. They are a counter to the assumption that lawn is free.
How to take lawn out, if you decide to:
| Method | Time | Effort | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cut and lift the turf with a spade or a turf cutter | Immediate | Hard physical work | You then have the turf to deal with; stacked grass-side down it rots into soil in a year, which is Learn Composting's chapter on leaves, grass and yard waste |
| Smother with cardboard and mulch | Several months | Light, spread over a weekend | Slow, cheap, and it leaves the soil undisturbed; plan it a season ahead |
| Dig it in | Immediate | Hard, and it brings up weed seed | Grass regrows from fragments; usually the least satisfactory route |
| Hire it removed | Immediate | None, for money | A quote item like any other; see Phasing the work |
If the lawn is the only safe surface a child or a dog uses, removing it is a change to how your household lives, not a design improvement, and it belongs in the brief rather than in a layout drawing. The same applies to removing the only flat, open ground on a sloping lot. Decide it with whoever uses it, and if the decision is to keep the lawn, keep it deliberately and put the planting where the lawn was not being used.
6. Views: what to frame and what to hide
Most people see their garden through a window far more often than they stand in it, which makes the view from inside a design input rather than an afterthought.
Oklahoma State Extension's method is to identify the locations you most often view the landscape from, inside and out, go to each one and look in all directions, within and beyond the property line, and decide what you want to enhance and what you want to hide. NC State Extension asks the same question. Put the answers on the survey's views sheet: seen from, looking toward, what you see, and whether to frame it or screen it.
Framing means arranging planting so that something worth looking at is seen between or past it: a tree on a neighboring lot, a church spire, a hill, a piece of sky. Oklahoma State describes plantings as able to create lines that direct the eye toward an interesting view or away from an undesirable one. It costs nothing but position.
Screening is sized by geometry and has a published floor. Alabama Extension says a screen needs to be at least 6 feet high to be effective, and that evergreens are an important part of a screen but should not be the only plants in it, with deciduous plants added for variety in color and texture.
The geometry people get wrong is this: a screen is sized from where you stand, not from the thing being hidden. A garage wall 40 feet away, seen from a kitchen window 5 feet off the ground, is hidden by a much shorter screen placed close to the window than by a tall one placed at the far end. Physical principle Sight lines are straight; what matters is the angle from eye to object, and anything on that line blocks it. Stand at the window, have somebody hold a cane where the screen might go, and mark the height at which the object disappears. That five-minute exercise replaces a great deal of guessing and frequently halves the height of plant you need.
7. Service: bins, storage and getting things in
NC State Extension's three-area model gives the service area its own name for a reason: the work of a house has to happen somewhere, and if it is not designed it happens in the best spot.
What belongs here: bins, recycling, firewood, compost, tools, hoses, a potting area, the place things get stacked during a project. What the design has to provide is not just space but a route, at the width the thing travels: a wheeled bin to the street, a wheelbarrow to the back, a mower out of the shed.
NC State's chapter also raises keeping vehicle access to the back of the property where it exists. That one matters more than it sounds for anybody planning in phases, because a delivery of soil, gravel or paving either comes in by truck or comes in by barrow, and the difference is measured in half-days. Any planting, fence or gate that closes off vehicle access has quietly repriced every future phase. If you have access, decide deliberately whether to keep it. If you do not, Phasing the work is where that cost shows up.
Service areas are also the right place for the things a screen is for, which brings sections 6 and 7 together: a bin store that is screened from the kitchen window and accessible from the street is doing both jobs, and the screen is sized by the window, not by the bins.
8. Proportion in a small space
There is a body of practitioner advice about making small spaces work and feel larger. It is worth knowing and worth labeling, because almost none of it is sourced to anything testable.
The ideas that recur across the paid curricula surveyed for this manual, and in general garden writing:
- Do not divide a small space into many small pieces. Fewer, larger areas read as more space than several small ones.
- A path or a bed set on a diagonal uses the longest dimension of a rectangular lot, which is the diagonal.
- Hiding part of the space so that it is not all visible at once makes it feel larger, because the eye is not given the whole boundary at a glance.
- Finer-textured plants further away can increase the apparent distance. Alabama Extension puts the reverse of this in print: a fine-textured plant near the viewer with a coarse-textured plant further away gives a subtle sense of decreased distance and makes a property seem smaller.
- Continuity of surface, one paving material rather than three, reads larger than a patchwork.
Preference With the exception of the Alabama texture point, these are practitioners' habits rather than published findings, and this manual labels them as such rather than dressing them as rules. They are useful ideas to try on a bubble diagram, where trying costs nothing.
One published figure does belong here. Alabama Extension gives a proportion rule for planting at the corners of a house: a corner planting should not grow higher than two-thirds of the height of the eaves, and the publication itself adds that this is not a hard and fast rule and that creativity can override it. Convention Quoting the caveat along with the figure is the honest way to use it.
9. See it: three layouts See it
The Okonkwo back yard, Columbus, Ohio. Known: 48 by 32 feet, 1,536 square feet. The maple's canopy covers about a third of it in the northwest. Water stands on the west side. Uses from the brief: six at a table twice a month; two children and a terrier daily; the neighbor's garage wall hidden from the kitchen window; something for bees. Three bubble diagrams: (A) terrace by the back door, lawn in the middle, planting along the east fence; (B) terrace at the far southeast corner where the sun is, lawn between it and the house; (C) no lawn, a large terrace and wide beds. Sizing: a table for six with chairs out and walking room is about 14 by 11, which is 154 square feet, a tenth of the yard. Wisconsin's cross-check for four family members is 256 square feet, so their terrace is on the small side of the per-person figure and adequate for the furniture, which is the tradeoff they chose knowingly. Assumed: that the children's use of open ground continues for at least five years, which is their assumption and has an expiry date. Open: whether the wet west side can carry a bed or needs to stay as nothing, which Water, drainage and slope decides. What they chose: B, because staking A showed that a terrace by the door sat in the maple's afternoon shade, and C failed the brief's play requirement. The screen for the garage wall was sized by standing at the kitchen window with a cane: the wall disappeared behind a 7-foot line set 18 feet out, rather than the 12-foot trees they had been pricing.
Dee's back yard, Providence, Rhode Island. Known: 14 by 20 feet, 280 square feet, rented, no structures permitted, part sun to borderline full sun in the afternoon. Uses: one person with coffee most mornings, two friends occasionally, shade-tolerant planting visible from the kitchen. Sizing: a bistro table for two with chairs out and walking room is roughly 7 by 7, which is 49 square feet, a sixth of the yard. A table for six would be over half of it, which settles a question she had been carrying. Assumed: nothing material. Open: how much she wants to invest in a yard she may leave in two years, which Phasing the work treats as a phasing question rather than a design one. What she chose: one area rather than three, which is the small-space advice in section 8 applied: a single paved corner for the table, with containers and a bed on two sides and nothing in the middle. Staking it showed that splitting the yard into a sitting corner, a growing corner and a bin corner, which had been her first diagram, left three pieces none of which worked.
Harlan's front yard, Austin, Texas. Known: 30 by 22 feet, 660 square feet, full afternoon sun, St. Augustine lawn to be removed, HOA approval required, hired out. Uses: walking from the car to the door, and being seen. Sizing: the only circulation is the walk, so the sizing question is the walk's width rather than a sitting area. Assumed: that the HOA's "maintained" requirement is about appearance rather than about grass specifically, which is his assumption and is the single most important open question in his whole project. Open: exactly that, and only the board settles it. What he chose: a bubble diagram with the lawn gone, wide planted beds either side of a widened walk, and a mown strip of a low groundcover along the sidewalk edge. The mown strip is there for a reason covered in Native plants and pollinators: a defined edge is most of what makes a planting read as deliberate rather than neglected, and his constraint makes that a requirement rather than a preference.
- Alabama Cooperative Extension System, Residential Landscape Design (ANR-0813, revised September 2019): defined mulched beds, the 6-foot screen, the two-thirds-of-the-eaves corner rule with its own caveat, and the texture-and-distance observation.
- UF/IFAS Extension, Landscape Design: Drawing a Planting Plan (ENH1195): the 5-to-30-foot bed depth range and the wide-curve guidance for bed lines.
- Oklahoma State University Extension, Planning the Landscape: the bubble diagram method and the views exercise.
10. Practice: three bubble diagrams and a stake-out Practice
Minimum: three bubble diagrams, one chosen, and its main area staked on the ground. Time: about 40 minutes drawing, 20 minutes staking, then a day of looking at it. Materials: tracing paper or photocopies of the base plan, a pencil, scissors and paper for furniture cut-outs, canes or stakes and string, or a hose for a bed line.
- Copy the base plan three times, or lay tracing paper over it. Mark the survey findings on each copy first: wet, shade, marked lines, hot wall.
- Draw three genuinely different diagrams, not three versions of one. Label every bubble with its use.
- Cut paper furniture to scale and lay it on the one you like best. Add 2 to 3 feet of walking room around chairs, as NC State Extension suggests, before you decide it fits.
- Stake it on the ground. Canes at the corners, string between them, or a hose for a curved bed edge. Walk around it, sit in the middle of it, carry something through it.
- Look at it from the window you use most, and at dusk as well as in daylight. Leave it staked overnight and look again in the morning before you decide.
Borrowed views
Anything worth looking at beyond your boundary is available to your design for free, and it is the one way a small garden can borrow size. A neighbor's tree, a distant roofline, a piece of sky between two buildings. Oklahoma State Extension's instruction to look beyond the property line when surveying views is the hook for this. The risk is that it is borrowed: a borrowed tree can be felled and a borrowed gap can be built on, so do not design something that only works because of it.
Designing a space whose use changes in five years
Where the brief has an expiry date, as a play lawn does, the move is to put the money into the things that serve any use and the temporary arrangements into the things that serve this one. Level ground, a path, a boundary and a tree serve a play lawn and whatever replaces it. A fixed structure on a concrete pad serves one use and then has to be demolished. The bubble diagram is the right place to notice which of your bubbles is permanent.
The three-zone model where it does not fit
NC State Extension's public, private and service division assumes a lot with a front, a back and somewhere out of sight. On a narrow urban lot, a corner lot, or a property where the kitchen door opens onto the drive, it will not map, and that is useful rather than a failure: the model has done its job if it makes you notice that the bins have nowhere to go, or that two sides of your lot are public. Where it does not fit, size the uses and place them on their merits.
11. Your garden Your garden
12. Check your work Check your work
Criteria
- Three bubble diagrams exist, and they are genuinely different from each other.
- Each carries the survey's findings, not just the wish list.
- Every area has a size worked out from what goes in it, with walking room counted.
- The chosen version has been staked on the ground and looked at for at least a day.
- Bed depths are a decision, with the mature spread of what will go in them considered.
- The lawn decision has a reason beside it, either way.
- Screens are sized by standing at the viewing point, not by guessing at the object.
- Bins, storage and their routes have a place, and vehicle access is a conscious decision.
Worked example
The Okonkwo layout (fictional) meets the criteria and the part worth copying is the staking. On paper, diagram A looked obvious: terrace by the back door, shortest carry from the kitchen. Staked on the ground and looked at over an afternoon, it sat in the maple's shade from two o'clock, which is exactly when a table gets used in summer. That is not something a drawing shows, and it is not something the sun readings showed either, because they were taken as hours of direct sun rather than as "where will we want to sit at 4 p.m. in July." The cane test for the screen is the other transferable piece: standing at the window and finding the height at which the garage disappeared replaced a 12-foot tree with a 7-foot screen, which changed what was affordable and what the bed had to be deep enough to hold.
Common mistakes
- One diagram. The first idea is rarely the best and is the hardest to let go of.
- Drawing without the survey on the sheet, and siting the terrace on the wet corner.
- Sizing by eye. A sitting area drawn freehand is usually about two-thirds of what the furniture needs.
- Forgetting chairs pull out, and that somebody has to walk behind them.
- Beds too shallow for the plants that will go in them.
- Wiggly bed lines, which a mower will not follow and which are gone in two seasons.
- Keeping or removing lawn by default rather than by decision.
- Sizing a screen from the thing being hidden instead of from where you stand.
- Closing off vehicle access without noticing what it does to every later phase.
What is still unresolved
- What the hard surfaces are made of, how wide and how steep: Paths, patios and structures.
- How many plants the beds you have drawn will actually hold: Drawing the planting plan, and it will be fewer than you expect.
- Which plants suit each area's measured conditions: Choosing plants that fit the place.
- What any of this costs and in what order it happens: Phasing the work.
- Whether a change to the front is permitted: your HOA board or local ordinance, not this manual.