Drawing the planting plan: circles at mature size, counted and spaced
Every plant drawn as a circle at its mature spread, spacing written on center, quantities counted by arithmetic rather than guessed, and a list a nursery can quote from.
- Start here: the essentials
- 1. The order UF/IFAS gives, and why
- 2. Bed lines first
- 3. A plant is a circle at its mature spread
- 4. Spacing on center, and the arithmetic of a count
- 5. Massing and repetition
- 6. Distances: walls, paths and boundaries
- 7. Bloom succession across the whole plan
- 8. What to leave empty
- 9. The plant list a nursery can quote from
- 10. See it: two counts
- 11. Practice: draw one bed and count it by hand
- 12. Your garden
- 13. Check your work
- 14. Knowledge check and scenario
Start here Essentials
This is where the manual's arithmetic lands. Do the first count by hand, on paper, before you use a calculator, because the number comes out smaller than anyone expects and you have to believe it. Everything marked Go deeper is optional on a first pass.
- Draw the bed line first, on the base plan, before any plant goes on it (section 2).
- Draw each plant as a circle at its mature spread, at the plan's scale (section 3).
- Count how many fit without the circles overlapping (section 4).
- Adjust the list to the count, not the count to the list (section 4).
Minimum time: about 40 minutes for one bed. Done when: you have a drawing whose circles do not overlap, with a number beside each species.
1. The order UF/IFAS gives, and why Understand
UF/IFAS Extension sets out the planting plan as a sequence, and it is worth following because each step constrains the next.
- Concept or functional plan. The general layout of plant material, with notes about what each planted area is for: shade, privacy, controlling views, hiding utilities, drawing attention to an entry. This is your bubble diagram from Beds, lawn and use areas, with the functions written on it.
- Master plant list. Candidates that suit the site conditions, which is Choosing plants that fit the place. UF/IFAS is explicit that growing requirements come first and visual characteristics second.
- Preliminary planting plan. Assign a plant from the list to each planted area, matching both the aesthetic notes and the growing requirements for that spot.
- Locate and draw the plant beds. The bed lines.
- Locate the structural plants. The large material that holds the design together.
- Locate the focal and anchor plants. The pieces that draw the eye and tie things down.
The sequence is not linear in practice, and UF/IFAS says so: decisions about plant material sometimes require reworking an earlier step. Convention What matters is the dependency, which is that a plant has no place until you know what the area is for and what the site is like, and a bed has nothing to fill until its line is drawn.
It also notes a practical point about restrictive conditions: where growing conditions are hard, such as deep shade or very moist soil, the requirements may limit the plant choices. On a small lot with a measured survey that is normal rather than unfortunate, and it is a relief: a short list of plants that will actually grow is easier to design with than a long list of possibilities.
2. Bed lines first
Draw the shape of the bed before you put anything in it. The reasoning is the same as drawing a room before buying furniture: the container sets what fits.
What decides a bed line:
- What the bed is for, from the concept plan. A screen has to be long enough to screen; a foundation planting runs where the foundation runs.
- Depth, which is the decision from Beds, lawn and use areas. UF/IFAS gives a typical range of 5 feet for a shallow bed to 30 feet for a deep one.
- Maintenance. UF/IFAS's guidance on bed lines is to use very wide, deep curves, half circles or three-quarter circles, at outside and inside corners. A line you can mow round survives; a wiggle does not.
- What is left. The lawn, path or terrace that remains should be a shape in its own right rather than an offcut.
Lay the line with a hose on the ground before you commit it to paper, and look at it from the window. Then draw it on the base plan at scale, because the next step needs an area to divide.
3. A plant is a circle at its mature spread
This is the central convention of the whole manual.
UF/IFAS Extension's method is to draw each plant as a circle at its mature spread, at the plan's scale. Mississippi State Extension gives the same instruction from the drafting side: at a scale of 1 inch = 10 feet, a plant with a mature size of about 5 feet is drawn with a circle half an inch across, and a smaller plant gets a proportionally smaller circle. Both recommend a circle template, which is a plastic stencil of circles in graded sizes from any office supplier.
Convention The convention is simple and its consequences are not. Drawing at mature spread means the plan shows the bed as it will be in ten years rather than as it will be in June. That is the only way to find out whether the design works, and it is also the reason a correctly drawn plan looks sparse and a correctly planted bed looks sparse for two summers.
To draw a circle at scale, convert: at 1/4 inch = 1 foot, a 3-foot plant is a 3/4-inch circle. At 1 inch = 10 feet, the same plant is a 0.3-inch circle. The site plan tool does this for you and reads mature widths straight off the plant list: you type a mature width in feet and the sheet fills an inches column beside it, which is what the plan uses, because the plan works in inches and gardeners work in feet.
Two habits that make the drawing honest:
- Draw the circle before you decide you want the plant. It is much harder to talk yourself into a 10-foot shrub once you have put a 10-foot circle on a 12-foot bed.
- Use the largest credible mature size where the plant is near a wall, a path or a boundary, for the reason in Choosing plants that fit the place: a plant that stays smaller is a minor disappointment, and one that gets bigger is a chainsaw.
4. Spacing on center, and the arithmetic of a count
UF/IFAS writes spacing as "o.c.", on center. "3' o.c." means plants with a 3-foot mature spread set 3 feet apart, measured center to center, so that they touch at mature size. That definition is the whole of the arithmetic.
So each plant occupies a square of ground spacing by spacing. In a square grid:
number of plants = usable bed area ÷ (spacing × spacing)
Work it. A bed 12 feet by 4 is 48 square feet. A plant with a 2-foot mature spread is set 2 feet on center and occupies 4 square feet. Forty-eight divided by four is twelve plants. Not forty. Twelve, for the whole bed, all species together.
Staggered rows pack a little closer. In a triangular arrangement, where each row is offset by half a spacing, each plant occupies 0.866 times spacing squared, because the rows sit closer together by a factor of the square root of 3 over 2. Physical principle That factor is geometry, not a horticultural recommendation: it is what you get from packing circles in a hexagonal pattern rather than a square one. The same 48-square-foot bed at 2-foot triangular spacing holds 48 ÷ (0.866 × 4), which is about 13.
The plant count calculator does both patterns and subtracts any percentage of the bed you are keeping clear. But do the first one by hand, with a pencil, because a number that comes out of a box is easy to disbelieve and a number you derived yourself is not.
| Bed | Area | At 1 ft o.c. | At 2 ft o.c. | At 3 ft o.c. | At 5 ft o.c. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 12 ft × 4 ft | 48 sq ft | 48 | 12 | 5 | 1 |
| 20 ft × 6 ft | 120 sq ft | 120 | 30 | 13 | 4 |
| 30 ft × 10 ft | 300 sq ft | 300 | 75 | 33 | 12 |
Read the last column. A 12-by-4-foot bed holds one shrub with a 5-foot mature spread. That is the arithmetic that stops people buying eleven of them, and it is also the arithmetic that explains every foundation planting you have ever seen pressed against a window.
Then comes the instruction in the Start here box, which is the hard part: adjust the list to the count, not the count to the list. When the arithmetic says five and you want eleven, the options are a bigger bed, smaller plants, or fewer plants. The option that is not available is eleven plants at 3-foot spacing in a bed that holds five, which is simply planting a bed that will be overcrowded in year five and ripped out in year seven.
A bed spaced at mature size is visibly bare for two summers, and nothing in this chapter changes that. In year one, plants are at roughly a third of their mature spread, so a correctly planted bed covers about a ninth of the ground it eventually will. The honest responses are patience, annuals or short-lived perennials in the gaps, and a thicker mulch for the first two seasons. The dishonest response, which is what most people do, is more shrubs. That buys two good summers and then a decade of pruning or a replanting, and it is the single commonest mistake in home planting.
5. Massing and repetition
Having counted, decide how the count is arranged.
NC State Extension's design principles include rhythm and unity, and the practical form of both in a small planting is repetition: the same plant appearing several times through a bed ties it together, while one of everything reads as a collection. Convention This is also the cheapest design decision available, because it costs nothing at the point of counting: twelve plants can be twelve species or four species repeated three times, and the second reads better and is easier to buy, plant and look after.
Massing means grouping several of one plant together rather than spacing them individually through the bed, which gives the planting blocks of texture and color rather than a speckle. In a bed holding twelve plants, three groups of four reads as a design and twelve singletons reads as a nursery.
Odd numbers are the advice you will meet everywhere: plant in threes, fives, sevens. Preference This manual labels it a practitioner's habit rather than a rule, because no source read for this manual gives a reason for it beyond that it tends to look less static. It is a harmless habit and worth knowing it is a habit.
One place where repetition does real work is the problem from Native plants and pollinators: a mixed native planting reads as deliberate when a plant repeats through it and as neglect when it does not. The counting step is where that gets decided.
6. Distances: walls, paths and boundaries
Three distances come out of the mature spread, and all three are measured from the center of the plant.
From a wall. NC State Extension: half the mature width plus at least 1 foot. A 5-foot shrub sits 3 1/2 feet out from the structure. Draw it that way and the circle will show you whether the bed is deep enough; frequently it is not, and the answer is a smaller plant.
From a path. A plant at mature spread overhangs the path by half its spread minus its distance from the edge. So a 3-foot plant whose center is 1 foot from the path edge reaches 6 inches over it, narrowing the path by that much on that side. Physical principle That is arithmetic, and it is the reason a path designed at 4 feet becomes 3 feet in year six. The site plan tool flags any measurement that falls below the path width you have set, which is 54 inches by default, NC State's 4 1/2-foot minimum for a front walk two people use abreast.
From a boundary. A plant at mature spread whose center is less than half its spread from the line will grow over it, which is your neighbor's problem and then yours. Ask the authority What the law says about overhanging branches varies by state and is not a question this manual answers; Learn Conflict Management's chapter on neighbors, landlords and people you hired is a better first stop than a hedge trimmer.
Alabama Extension adds one more: do not plant trees and shrubs where their roots will interfere with water and sewer lines. The marked lines from Measuring and drawing your site belong on this drawing, not only on the one you dig from.
7. Bloom succession across the whole plan
Native plants and pollinators introduced the bloom chart for a pollinator planting. At this stage run it across the whole plan, not just the part planted for wildlife, for a second reason: a garden with flower in two months and nothing in the other six is a garden you stop looking at.
The method is the same. Row per plant, column per month, tick where it flowers where you live. Then read the empty columns and the crowded ones.
Three questions the chart answers that a list does not:
- Which month has nothing? Usually early spring or late summer, and it is the gap worth spending a plant on.
- Which month has everything? A plan where eight of twelve plants flower in June is a plan with one good fortnight.
- What happens when nothing is flowering? Which is the question Alabama Extension's 80-to-90-percent-foliage figure answers: most of what you look at, most of the time, is leaves.
Year-round interest comes from more than bloom, and the chart can carry extra rows for it: evergreen structure, fall color, fruit, bark and seedheads. In a small garden these matter more than flower, because there is less of everything and you see all of it from the window every day.
8. What to leave empty
A plan with no empty ground on it is a plan that has not finished thinking.
- The bare-ground patch from Native plants and pollinators, for ground-nesting bees. Mark it, and exclude it from the mulch order.
- Room to get in. A bed deeper than about 4 feet needs somewhere to put your feet, or you will be standing on the plants at the front to reach the ones at the back.
- Space you have not decided about. Leaving a part of a bed empty for a season is a legitimate decision, and it is cheaper than filling it with something you will remove.
- The space a future plant needs. If a tree is going in next year, its circle is on the plan this year, and nothing permanent goes inside it.
The plant count calculator has a field for the percentage of a bed kept clear, which handles the first and second of those in the arithmetic rather than in good intentions.
9. The plant list a nursery can quote from
The output of this chapter is two things: a drawing and a list. The list is what you take to a nursery or give to a contractor, and UF/IFAS's example plant schedules carry the fields that make one quotable.
| Field | Why it is on the list |
|---|---|
| Botanical name | The only unambiguous identifier; common names are regional and reused |
| Cultivar, in single quotes | Changes the size, and sometimes the value to pollinators |
| Quantity | From the count, not from a feeling |
| Size sold | Container size or caliper; it is what the price attaches to |
| Spacing, as o.c. | So whoever plants it knows the intent, and so the count can be checked |
| Mature height and spread | So a substitution can be judged rather than accepted |
| Where it goes | Keyed to the drawing |
The mature size column is the one that protects you. A nursery or a contractor that is out of a plant will offer a substitute, and the substitution is reasonable only if the replacement is the same size at maturity. Convention A list without mature sizes makes every substitution a guess; a list with them makes it a comparison you can do in thirty seconds.
The plant list carries all of these columns, totals the quantity and the line cost, and leaves a price blank until a real one exists, because a blank reads as unknown and a zero means free.
10. See it: two counts See it
Rosalind's strip, Burlington, Vermont. Known: 12 by 4 feet, which is 48 square feet, with a marked gas line and a no-dig zone down the middle. Three shortlisted perennials with mature spreads of 1 1/2, 2 and 3 feet. She wants a square foot of bare ground. By hand, before the calculator: usable area is 48 square feet less 1 for the bare patch, and she set aside a further 20 percent as the no-dig strip she will plant only with shallow-rooted material, leaving about 37 square feet for the main planting. At 2 feet on center, 37 ÷ 4 is 9 plants. At 3 feet on center it would be 4. Assumed: that the three species can be mixed at a single average spacing, which is a simplification; the accurate method is to run the calculator once per species for the share of the bed it occupies. She did it the simple way first to get the order of magnitude and then the careful way. Open: how the no-dig zone restricts root depth, which is the utility's answer and not hers. What it changed: she had a list of seven plants and the bed holds about nine individuals in total. Under these assumptions the list came down to three species: three of the 3-foot plant down the center line, repeated, with the smaller two filling between them. Three of one plant repeated is also what makes it read as deliberate from the sidewalk, so the arithmetic and the design decision landed in the same place.
The Okonkwo screen bed, Columbus, Ohio. Known: the screen for the neighbor's garage wall, sized by the cane test in Beds, lawn and use areas at 7 feet high and 18 feet out from the kitchen window. The bed is 18 feet long and 6 feet deep, which is 108 square feet. The shrub they want has a mature spread of 6 feet and a mature height of 8. By hand: at 6 feet on center, 108 ÷ 36 is 3 plants. Three shrubs, 6 feet apart, for an 18-foot screen. The check against the bed: a 6-foot plant in a 6-foot-deep bed, with NC State's half-the-width-plus-a-foot rule against the fence, puts each center 4 feet from the fence, leaving 2 feet in front, so the circles overhang the front edge by a foot. Assumed: that the fence counts as a structure for the setback rule, which is their reading and is conservative. Open: whether three plants read as a screen before year six. What it changed: they widened the bed to 7 feet, which absorbs the overhang, and accepted that a screen of three shrubs at mature spacing is a gappy screen for several years. The alternative they rejected was five shrubs at 4-foot spacing, which would screen faster and then be a hedge requiring annual cutting, forever. That is the trade the arithmetic makes visible and it is worth making knowingly.
- UF/IFAS Extension, Landscape Design: Drawing a Planting Plan (ENH1195): the six-step sequence, the circle at mature spread, the o.c. convention and the bed-depth range.
- Mississippi State University Extension, Home Landscape Design: drawing plant symbols to scale with a circle template, with a worked example at 1 inch = 10 feet.
- NC State Extension Gardener Handbook, chapter 19: distance from structures, the design principles behind repetition, and the mature-size warning about scale.
11. Practice: draw one bed and count it by hand Practice
Minimum: one bed drawn at scale, with every plant as a circle at mature spread, counted by hand. Time: about 40 minutes. Materials: the base plan, a pencil, a ruler, a compass or a circle template, and the plant list with mature widths filled in.
- Draw the bed line at scale on a copy of the base plan, and write the scale on the sheet.
- Work out the area and subtract anything you are keeping clear: the bare patch, a place to stand, a feature.
- Do the division on paper for your largest plant first: area divided by spacing squared. Write the number down before you draw anything.
- Draw that many circles at mature spread, placed where you want them, not overlapping. Check the distance from the wall is half the width plus a foot.
- Fill between them with the smaller plants, doing the same division for the area left over.
- Count what is on the page, write the number beside each species on the plant list, and compare it with what you had hoped for. Adjust the list, not the drawing.
- Run it through the plant count calculator as a check on your arithmetic.
By hand against the site plan tool
Paper is better for thinking and the tool is better for checking. On paper you can see the whole bed at once, erase freely and sketch three versions in the time the tool takes to load. The site plan tool earns its place afterward: it holds the drawing at a true scale, it reads mature widths straight off the plant list so a transcription error cannot creep in, it flags a path that a plant at mature size would narrow below your path width, and it prints at scale with a scale bar you can check against a ruler. Use both, in that order.
Drawing a plan for a slope
A plan is a view from above, so a slope appears foreshortened: 20 feet of sloping ground covers less than 20 feet on the plan. For a gentle slope the difference is small enough to ignore. For a steep one it is not, and the plant circles drawn on it will be too close together on the ground. The practical fix is to measure horizontally, as Measuring and drawing your site describes, and to treat the plan as approximate on anything steep.
How a designer's planting plan differs from this one
A professional plan carries more: a full schedule with sizes and specifications, planting details, a key keyed to a drawing a contractor can work from, and often a maintenance schedule. It is a document for somebody else to build from, which is its purpose. What this chapter gives you is the same arithmetic and a drawing good enough to buy from and plant from yourself. If you hire a designer later, the mature-size column on your plant list is what lets you read their plan critically, and asking them for mature height and spread on every line is a reasonable request.
12. Your garden Your garden
13. Check your work Check your work
Criteria
- The bed line was drawn before any plant was placed.
- Every plant is drawn as a circle at its mature spread, at the stated scale.
- No two circles overlap.
- The count came from dividing area by spacing squared, done at least once by hand.
- Plants near a wall sit at half their mature width plus at least a foot from it.
- No plant at mature spread narrows a path below the width you set for it.
- Nothing at mature spread crosses a boundary line.
- The bloom chart covers the whole plan, not just the pollinator part.
- Something is deliberately left empty, and it is marked.
- The plant list carries botanical name, cultivar, quantity, size sold, spacing and mature size.
Worked example
The Okonkwo screen bed (fictional) is the better worked example because of the trade it makes visible. Three shrubs at 6 feet on center for an 18-foot screen is what the arithmetic gives, and it will be a gappy screen until about year six. Five shrubs at 4 feet would screen faster. The arithmetic is what lets them see that the second option is not "a denser screen" but "a hedge that has to be cut every year forever," because five 6-foot plants in 18 feet are overlapping by 2 feet each at maturity. Having seen it, they chose three, widened the bed from 6 feet to 7 to absorb the front overhang, and decided to live with a thin screen for a few years. The weakness they accepted knowingly is that the screen does not do its job yet, and the honest mitigations are the ones in the Limits box: patience, or something temporary in front of it that comes out later.
Common mistakes
- Drawing plants at the size they are sold, which produces a bed that is full for two years and a thicket after that.
- Overplanting deliberately "to thin later." Almost nobody thins later.
- Adjusting the count to the list instead of the list to the count.
- Forgetting the half-width-plus-a-foot rule and pressing shrubs against the house.
- Ignoring what a mature plant does to a path width.
- Planting one of everything, which reads as a collection and is harder to buy and maintain.
- Leaving no gaps, including no bare ground and nowhere to stand.
- A plant list with common names and no mature sizes, which makes every substitution a guess.
- Trusting the calculator before doing one count by hand, because then the number is not believed and gets quietly ignored at the nursery.
What is still unresolved
- What any of it costs and when it happens: Phasing the work, with your own quotes.
- How to get plants into the ground and keep them alive: Planting and the first three years.
- Whether a substitution a nursery offers is equivalent: the mature size column, and your own judgment.
- How fast a plant actually reaches its mature spread, which varies by species, soil and water, and which no plan can tell you.
- Whether a bed you drew is in an easement or over a marked line: the plat and the locate, from Measuring and drawing your site.